among all nations, beginning at Jerusalem;2199 and we are bound to hold firmly this rule,
“If any preach any other gospel unto you than that ye have received, let him be accursed.”2200
Chap. VIII.
24. If, moreover, we do not listen to the claims of the entire sect of Donatists when they
pretend to be the Church of Christ, seeing that they do not allege in proof of this anything
from the Divine Books, how much less, I ask, are we called upon to listen to the Rogatists,
who will not attempt to interpret; in the interest of their party the words of Scripture: “Where
Thou feedest, where Thou dost rest in the south”!2201 For if by this the southern part of
Africa is to be understood,—the district, namely, which is occupied by Donatists, because
it is under a more burning portion of the heavens,—the Maximianists must excel all the rest
of your party, as the flame of their schism broke forth in Byzantium2202 and in Tripoli. Let
the Arzuges, if they please, dispute this point with them, and contest that to them more
properly this text applies; but how shall the imperial province of Mauritania, lying rather
to the west than to the south, since it refuses to be called Africa,—how shall it, I say, find in
the word “the south”2203 a ground for boasting, I do not say against the world, but against
even that sect of Donatus from which the sect of Rogatus, a very small fragment of that
other and larger fragment, has been broken off? For what else is it than superlative impudence
for one to interpret in his own favour any allegorical statements, unless he has also plain
testimonies, by the light of which the obscure meaning of the former may be made manifest.
25. With how much greater force, moreover, may we say to you what we are accustomed
to say to all the Donatists: If any can have good grounds (which indeed none can have) for
separating themselves from the communion of the whole world, and calling their communion
the Church of Christ, because of their having withdrawn warrantably from the communion
of all nations,—how do you know that in the Christian society, which is spread so far and
wide, there may not have been some in a very remote place, from which the fame of their
righteousness could not reach you, who had already, before the date of your separation,
separated themselves for some just cause from the communion of the whole world? How
could the Church in that case be found in your sect, rather than in those who were separated
before you? Thus it comes to pass, that so long as you are ignorant of this, you cannot make
with certainty any claim: which is necessarily the portion of all who, in defending the cause
of their party, appeal to their own testimony instead of the testimony of God. For you cannot
say, If this had happened, it could not have escaped our knowledge; for, not going beyond
2199 Luke xxiv. 47.
2200 Gal. i. 9.
2201 Meridie; at noon, E. V. Cant. i. 7.
2202 Now Tunis.
2203 Meridie.
862
To Vincentius