Chapter 4.—Concerning Plato, the Chief Among the Disciples of Socrates, and His
Threefold Division of Philosophy.
But, among the disciples of Socrates, Plato was the one who shone with a glory which
far excelled that of the others, and who not unjustly eclipsed them all. By birth, an Athenian
of honorable parentage, he far surpassed his fellow-disciples in natural endowments, of
which he was possessed in a wonderful degree. Yet, deeming himself and the Socratic dis-
cipline far from sufficient for bringing philosophy to perfection, he travelled as extensively
as he was able, going to every place famed for the cultivation of any science of which he
could make himself master. Thus he learned from the Egyptians whatever they held and
taught as important; and from Egypt, passing into those parts of Italy which were filled with
the fame of the Pythagoreans, he mastered, with the greatest facility, and under the most
eminent teachers, all the Italic philosophy which was then in vogue. And, as he had a pecu-
liar love for his master Socrates, he made him the speaker in all his dialogues, putting into
his mouth whatever he had learned, either from others, or from the efforts of his own
powerful intellect, tempering even his moral disputations with the grace and politeness of
the Socratic style. And, as the study of wisdom consists in action and contemplation, so
that one part of it may be called active, and the other contemplative,—the active part having
reference to the conduct of life, that is, to the regulation of morals, and the contemplative
part to the investigation into the causes of nature and into pure truth,—Socrates is said to
have excelled in the active part of that study, while Pythagoras gave more attention to its
contemplative part, on which he brought to bear all the force of his great intellect. To Plato
is given the praise of having perfected philosophy by combining both parts into one. He
then divides it into three parts,—the first moral, which is chiefly occupied with action; the
second natural, of which the object is contemplation; and the third rational, which discrim-
inates between the true and the false. And though this last is necessary both to action and
contemplation, it is contemplation, nevertheless, which lays peculiar claim to the office of
147
investigating the nature of truth. Thus this tripartite division is not contrary to that which
made the study of wisdom to consist in action and contemplation. Now, as to what Plato
thought with respect to each of these parts,—that is, what he believed to be the end of all
actions, the cause of all natures, and the light of all intelligences,—it would be a question
too long to discuss, and about which we ought not to make any rash affirmation. For, as
Plato liked and constantly affected the well-known method of his master Socrates, namely,
that of dissimulating his knowledge or his opinions, it is not easy to discover clearly what
he himself thought on various matters, any more than it is to discover what were the real
opinions of Socrates. We must, nevertheless, insert into our work certain of those opinions
which he expresses in his writings, whether he himself uttered them, or narrates them as
expressed by others, and seems himself to approve of,—opinions sometimes favorable to
the true religion, which our faith takes up and defends, and sometimes contrary to it, as, for
Concerning Plato, the Chief Among the Disciples of Socrates, and His Threefold Division of Philosophy.
340
Concerning Plato, the Chief Among the Disciples of Socrates, and His Threefold…