up themselves to him, to be ruled, taught, and led by him; such as with all their hearts cast
themselves on the mercy of God to enable them to keep covenant; such as professed to love
God above the world, and professed more than common faith and moral sincerity, even
true holiness, real piety; and who gave moral evidence, that they had such a qualification;
and were received to the passover, &c. under that notion, and with respect to such a character
appearing in them, and apprehended to be in them. And if these things are so, what is become
of the argument from the passover and circumcision, against the necessity of the qualifications
I have insisted on?
20. To what purpose does Mr. W. insist, (p. 98. a.) That we read not a word in Scripture
about John the Baptist’s making any inquiry, whether the people he baptized made a credible
profession of true piety? when he himself insists, that in order to admission to christian
sacraments, men must make a credible profession of true piety. And why does he urge, (p.
96. e. and p. 97.) That the profession the people made which John baptized did not imply
that they had saving repentance, but only an engagement to repent, hereafter? when he
himself holds, that in order to admission to sacraments, men must profess something more
than common grace, and not only promise it hereafter.
21. It makes nothing to any point in controversy between Mr. W. and me, whether Judas
partook of the Lord’s supper or no, since according to the fore-mentioned principles, as
well as mine, he could not be admitted there under any other notion than that of being truly
pious, and from respect to such a character appearing on him, and a credible profession of
gospel-holiness; and since he might not lawfully come without some qualifications he had
not, viz. such a friendship for Christ, as is above lukewarmness, and above serving two
masters, Christ and Mammon, and a giving up all his heart and life to Christ, and a real
determination of his judgment and affections for Christ’s word, &c.
22. If it be true, as Mr. W. allows, that ministers and churches ought not to admit adult
persons to sacraments, without a pious character appearing on them, and their professing
and exhibiting moral evidence of gospel-holiness, then no good argument can be brought
against such a way of admission, from the success of ministers in another way, or in any
495
way whatsoever.
Besides these plain and obvious consequences of Mr. W.‘s concessions, some other
consequences will hereafter be observed under particular heads.
Thus Mr. W. has in effect given up every point belonging to the whole controversy,
every thing material insisted on through that whole book which he undertakes to answer.
He has established every part of my scheme, and every particular argument I have used to
confirm it; and answered, or overthrown every argument which he brings, or pretends to
support, against it. And I should have no further occasion to say any thing in reply to him,
if he had not really, through great part of his performance, argued for other things, opposite
to those that have been rehearsed, which he so strenuously insists belong to his scheme.
1923
SECTION II. Consequences.