Chapter
XXIII
.—
Of what befell the orthodox
bishops at Constantinople
.
Constantius
, on his return from the West, passed some time at Constantinople.
There Acacius urged many accusations against the assembled bishops in
presence of the emperor, called them a set of vile characters convoked
for the ruin and destruction of the churches, and so fired the imperial
wrath. And not least was Constantius moved by what was alleged against
Cyrillus, “for,” said Acachius, “the holy robe, which
the illustrious Constantine the emperor, in his desire to honour the
church of Jerusalem, gave to Macarius, the bishop of that city, to be
worn when he performed the rite of divine baptism, all fashioned with
golden threads as it was, has been sold by Cyrillus. It has been
bought,” he continued, “by a certain stage dancer; dancing
about when he was wearing it, he fell down and perished. With a man
like this Cyrillus,” he went on, “they set themselves up to
judge and decide for the rest of the world.” The influential
party at the court made this an occasion for persuading the emperor not
to summon the whole synod, for they were alarmed at the concord of the
majority, but only ten leading men. Of these were Eustathius of
Armenia, Basilius of Galatia, Silvanus of Tarsus, and Eleusius of
Cyzicus.
578
On their arrival they urged the emperor that Eudoxius should be
convicted of blasphemy and lawlessness. Constantius, however, schooled
by the opposite party, replied that a decision must first be come to on
matters concerning the faith, and that afterwards the case of Eudoxius
should be enquired into. Basilius, relying on his former intimacy,
ventured boldly to object to the emperor that he was attacking the
apostolic decrees; but Constantius took this ill, and told Basilius to
hold his tongue, “for to you,” said he, “the
disturbance of the churches is due.” When Basilius was silenced,
Eustathius intervened and said, “since, sir, you wish a decision
to be come to on what concerns the faith, consider the blasphemies
rashly uttered against the Only Begotten by Eudoxius,” and as he
spoke he produced the exposition of faith wherein, besides many other
impieties, were found the following expressions: “Things that are
spoken of in unlike terms are unlike in substance:” “There
is one God the Father of whom are all things, and one Lord Jesus Christ
through whom are all things.” Now the term “of whom”
is unlike the term “through whom;” so the Son is unlike God
the Father. Constantius ordered this exposition of the faith to be
read, and was displeased with the blasphemy which it involved. He
therefore asked Eudoxius if he had drawn it up. Eudoxius instantly
repudiated the authorship, and said that it was written by Aetius. Now
Aetius was he whom Leontius, in dread of the accusations of Flavianus
and Diodorus, had formerly degraded from the diaconate. He had also
been the supporter of Georgius, the treacherous foe of the
Alexandrians, alike in his impious words and his unholy deeds. At the
present time he was associated with Eunomius and Eudoxius; for, on the
death of Leontius, when Eudoxius had laid violent hands on the
episcopal throne of the church at Antioch, he returned from Egypt with
Eunomius, and, as he found Eudoxius to be of the same way of thinking
as himself, a sybarite in luxury as well as a heretic in faith, he
chose Antioch as the most congenial place of abode, and both he and
Eunomius were fast fixtures at the couches of Eudoxius. His highest
ambition was to be a successful parasite, and he spent his whole time
in going to gorge himself at one man’s table or another’s.
The emperor had been told all this, and now ordered Aetius to be
brought before him. On his appearance Constantius showed him the
document in question and proceeded to enquire if he was the author of
its language. Aetius, totally ignorant of what had taken place, and
unaware of the drift of the enquiry, expected that he should win praise
by confession, and owned that he was the author of the phrases in
question. Then the emperor perceived the greatness of his iniquity, and
forthwith condemned him to exile and to be deported to a place in
Phrygia. So Aetius reaped disgrace as the fruit of blasphemy, and was
cast out of the palace. Eustathius then alleged that Eudoxius too held
the same views, for that Aetius had shared his roof and his table, and
had drawn up this blasphemous formula in submission to his judgement.
In proof of his contention that Eudoxius was concerned in drawing up
the document he urged the fact that no one had attributed it to Aetius
except Eudoxius himself. To this the emperor enjoined that judges must
not decide on conjecture, but are bound to make exact examination of
the facts. Eustathius assented, and urged that Eudoxius should give
proof of his dissent from the sentiments attributed to him by
anathematizing the composition of Aetius. This suggestion the emperor
very readily accepted, and gave his orders accordingly; but Eudoxius
drew back, and employed many shifts to evade compliance. But when the
emperor waxed wroth and threatened to send him off to share the exile
of Aetius, on the ground that he was a partner in the blasphemy so
punished, he repudiated his own doctrine, though both then and
afterwards he persistently maintained it. However, he in his turn
protested against the Eustathians that it was their duty to condemn the
word “
Homoüsion
” as unscriptural.
Silvanus on the contrary pointed
out that it was their duty to reject and expel from their holy
assemblies the phrases “
out of the non-existent
” and
“
creature
” and “
of another
substance,
” these terms being also unscriptural and found in
the writings of neither prophets nor apostles. Constantius decided that
this was right, and bade the Arians pronounce the condemnation. At
first they persisted in refusing; but in the end, when they saw the
emperor’s wrath, they consented, though much against the grain,
to condemn the terms Silvanus had put before them. But all the more
earnestly they insisted on their demand for the condemnation of the
“
Homoüsion.
” But then with unanswerable logic
Silvanus put both before the Arians and the emperor the truth that if
God the Word is not of the non-Existent, He is not a Creature, and is
not of another Substance. He is then of one Sub
stance with God Who begat Him,
as God of God and Light of Light, and has the same nature as the
Begetter. This contention he urged with power and with truth, but not
one of his hearers was convinced. The party of Acacius and Eudoxius
raised a mighty uproar; the emperor was angered, and threatened
expulsion from their churches. Thereupon Eleusius and Silvanus and the
rest said that while authority to punish lay with the emperor, it was
their province to decide on points of piety or impiety, and “we
will not,” they protested, “betray the doctrine of the
Fathers.”
Constantius ought to have
admired both their wisdom and their courage, and their bold defence of
the apostolic decrees, but he exiled them from their churches, and
ordered others to be appointed in their place. Thereupon Eudoxius laid
violent hands on the Church of Constantinople; and on the expulsion of
Eleusius from Cyzicus, Eunomius was appointed in his place.
578
i.e.
, Eustathius of Sebasteia, and
Basilius of Ancyra (vide note on p. 86). Silvanus of Tarsus was one of
the Semiarians of high character. For his kindly entertainment of Cyril
of Jerusalem vide page 87. Tillemont places his death in
363.
Eleusius of Cyzicus was
also a Semiarian of the better type (cf. Hil. de Syn. p. 133). The evil
genius of his life was Macedorius of Constantinople, by whose influence
he was made bishop of Cyzicus in 356. Here with equal zeal he destroyed
pagan temples and a Novatian church, and this was remembered against
him when he attempted to return to his see on the accession of Julian.
At Nicomedia in 366 he was moved by the threats of Valens to declare
himself an Arian and then in remorse resigned his see, but his flock
refused to let him go, Socr. iv. 6.