the truth. Some may be ready to say, that though it be the truth, yet the truth is not to be
spoken at all times, and seems not to be seasonable then. But it seems to me, such truth is
never more seasonable than at such at time, when Christ is beginning to open the eyes of
conscience. Ministers ought to act as co-workers with him; to take that opportunity, and to
the utmost to improve that advantage, and strike while the iron is hot. When the light has
begun to shine, then they should remove all obstacles, and use all proper means, that it may
come in more fully. And experience abundantly shows, that to take this course is not of a
hurtful tendency, but very much the contrary. I have seen, in very many instances, the happy
effects of it, and oftentimes a very speedy happy issue; and never knew any ill consequence,
in case of real conviction, and when distress has been only from thence.
I know of but one case, wherein the truth ought to be withheld from sinners in distress
of conscience, and that is the case of melancholy: and it is not to be withheld from them, as
if the truth tends to do them hurt; but because, if we speak the truth to them, sometimes
they will be deceived, and led into error by it, thought that strange disposition there is in
393
them to take things wrong. So that, though what is spoken is truth, yet as it is heard, received,
and applied by them, it is falsehood; as it will be, unless the truth be spoken with abundance
of caution and prudence, and consideration of their disposition and circumstances. But the
most awful truths of God’s word ought not to be withheld from public congregations, because
it may happen that some such melancholic persons may be in it: any more than the Bible is
to be withheld from the Christian world, because it is manifest that there are a great many
melancholic persons in Christendom that exceedingly abuse the awful things contained in
the Scripture, to their own wounding. Nor do I think that to be of weight, which is made
use of by some, as a great and dreadful objection against the terrifying preaching that has
of late been in New England, viz. That there have been some instances of melancholic persons
who have so abused it, that the issue has been the murder of themselves. The objection from
hence is no stronger against awakening preaching, than it is against the Bible itself. There
are hundreds, and probably thousands, of instances, of persons who have murdered them-
selves under religious melancholy. These murders probably never would have been, if the
world had remained in a state of heathenish darkness. The Bible has not only been the occa-
sion of these sad effects, but of thousands, and I suppose millions, of other cruel murders
committed in the persecutions that have been raised, which never would have been if it had
not been for the Bible. Many whole countries have been as it were deluged with innocent
blood, which would not have been if the gospel never had been preached in the world. It is
not a good objection against any kind of preaching that some men abuse it greatly to their
hurt. It has been acknowledged by all divines, as a thing common in all ages, and all Chris-
tian countries, that a very great part of those who sit under the gospel abuse it. It proves an
occasion of their far more aggravated damnation, and so of eternally murdering their souls;
which is an effect infinitely more terrible than the murder of their bodies. It is as unjust to
1636
PART III. Wherein the zealous Promoters of this Work have been injuriously…