17. But let us consider
what are the arguments by which he tries to prove that Origen’s
writings have been corrupted by the heretics.
“Clement,” he says,
“who was the disciple of the Apostles, and who succeeded the
apostles both in the episcopate and in martyrdom, wrote the books which
go by the name of Anagnorismus, that is, Recognitions. In these,
though, speaking generally, the doctrine which is set forth in the name
of the Apostle Peter is genuinely apostolical, yet in certain passages
the doctrine of Eunomius is brought in such a way as that you would
suppose Eunomius himself to be conducting the argument and asserting
his view that the Son was created out of nothing.”
And, after a passage too long to
reproduce, he adds:
“What then are we to think
of these facts? Must we believe that an Apostolic man wrote heresy? or
is it not more likely that men of perverse mind, wishing to gain
support for their own doctrines, and win easier credit for them,
introduced under the names of holy men views which they cannot be
believed either to have held or to have written down?”
He tells us that Clement the
presbyter of Alexandria also, who was a catholic man, writes at times
in his works that the Son of God is created; and that Dionysius Bishop
of Alexandria, a most learned man, in the four books in which he
controverted the doctrines of Sabellius, lapses into the dogma of
Arius. What he aims at by quoting these instances is not to shew that
Churchmen and catholics have erred, but that their writings have been
corrupted by heretics, and he closes the discussion with these
words:
“And when we find in
Origen a certain diversity of doctrine, just as we have found it in
those of whom we have spoken above, will it not be sufficient for us to
believe the same in his case which we believe or understand in the case
of the catholic men whom we have passed in review? Will not the same
defence hold good when the case is the same?”
If, I reply, we admit that
everything in a book which is offensive is corruptly inserted by
others, nothing will remain belonging to the author under whose name
the book passes, but everything can be assigned to those by whom it is
supposed to have been corrupted. But then it will not belong to them
either, since we do not know who they were: and the result will be that
every book belongs to everybody and nothing to any one in particular.
In this confusion which this method of defence introduces, it will be
impossible to convict Marcion of error, or Manichæus or Arius or
Eunomius; because, as soon as we point out a statement of their
unbelief, their disciples will answer that was not what the master
wrote, but was corruptly inserted by his opponents. According to this
principle, this very book of yours will not be yours nor mine. And as
to this very book in which I am making reply to your accusations,
whatever you find fault with in it will be held not be written by me
but by you who now find fault with it. And further, while you assign
everything to the heretics, there
will be nothing left which you
can assign to churchmen as their own.
But you may ask, How is it then
that in their books some false views occur? Well, if I answer that I do
not know the parties whence these false views came, I must not be
thought to have said that they are heretics. It is possible that they
may have fallen into error unawares, or that the words bore a different
meaning, or that they may have been gradually corrupted by unskilful
copyists. It must be admitted that, before Arius arose in Alexandria as
a demon of the south, things were said incautiously which cannot be
defended against a malevolent criticism. But when glaring faults are
exposed in Origen, you do not defend him but accuse others; you do not
deny the faults, but summon up a host of criminals. If you were asked
to name those who have been the companions of Origen in his heresies,
it would be right enough to call in these others. But what you are now
asked to tell us is whether those statements in the books of Origen are
good or evil; and you say nothing, but bring in irrelevant matters,
such as: This is what Clement says; this is an error of which Dionysius
is found guilty; these are the words in which the bishop Athanasius
defends the error of Dionysius; in a similar way the writings of the
Apostle have been tampered with: and then, while the charge of heresy
is fastened upon you, you say nothing in your own defence, but make
confessions about me. I make no accusations, and am content with
answering for myself. I am not what you try to prove me: whether you
are what you are accused of being, is for you to consider. The fact
that I am acquitted of blame does not prove me innocent nor the fact
that you are accused prove you a criminal.