VER. 4. ST. JOHN. 17
whichweremade by the Word, livein Him, and were made
inHim. HIIARI.Or itcan be understoodthus.In thathe
badsaid,withoutHim was notany thingmade,onemighthave
beenperplexed,and have asked,Was thenany thingmade by
another,whichyet was not made withoutHim ? ifso,then
thoughnothingis made without,allthingsarenot made by
Him : itbeingone thing to make, anotherto be with the
maker. On thisaccounttheEvangelistdeclareswhat itwas
which was not made withoutHim, viz.what was made in
Him. Thisthen itwas whichwas not made withoutHim,
viz.what was made in Him. And thatwhichwas made in
Him, was alsomade by Him. For allthingswerecreatedin
Him and by Him. Now thingswere made inHim, because
He was born God the Creator. And forthisreasonalso
thingsthatweremade in Him, were not made withoutHim,
viz.thatGod, in thatHe was born,was life,and He who
waslife,was not made lifeafterbeingborn. Nothingthen
whichwas made inHim, was made withoutHim, because
He was life,inWhom theywere made; becauseGod Who
was born of God was God, not after,but in thatHe was
bornh. CHRYS. Or to giveanotherexplanation.We willChrys.
not putthe stopatwithoutHim was not any thingmade,as riv^j'fa
thehereticsdo. For theywishingtoprovetheHoly Ghost Joan.a creature,read,Thatwhichwas made inHim, was life.But c''
thiscannotbe so understood.For first,thiswas not the
placeformaking mentionoftheHoly Ghost. But letus sup
poseitwas; letus takethe passageforthe presentaccord
ingtotheirreading,we shallseethatitleadstoa difficulty.
For when itis said,Thatwhichwas made inHim, was life;
theysaythelifespokenofistheHoly Ghost. But thislife
isalsolight; forthe Evangelistproceeds,The lifewas the
lightofmen. Wherefore accordingto them, he callsthe
Holy Ghostthe lightofallmen. But theWord mentioned
above,iswhat he here callsconsecutively,God, and Life,
and Light. Now theWord was made flesh.It followsthat
the Holy Ghostisincarnate,not theSon. Dismissingthen
thisreading,we adopta more suitableone,withthe follow-
* i*. the Son everbeing what He Creator,in that He was, and always
is,in thatHe is," Livingof Living, equallytheCreator,and soofallthings,
Perfectof Perfect,"not[as man] re- because what He was,He was always,
coring subsequently,He was the in thatHe was.
VOL. IV. c