Canon XX.
It shall not be lawful, as we have already decreed, for clergymen officiating in one church
to be appointed to the church of another city, but they shall cleave to that in which they
were first thought worthy to minister; those, however, being excepted, who have been
driven by necessity from their own country, and have therefore removed to another church.
And if, after this decree, any bishop shall receive a clergyman belonging to another bishop,
it is decreed that both the received and the receiver shall be excommunicated until such
time as the clergyman who has removed shall have returned to his own church.
Notes.
Ancient Epitome of Canon XX.
A clergyman of one city shall not be given a cure in another. But if he has been driven
from his native place and shall go into another he shall be without blame. If any bishop re-
ceives clergymen from without his diocese he shall be excommunicated as well as the cleric
he receives.
It is quite doubtful as to what “excommunication” means in this canon, probably not
anathematism (so think the commentators) but separation from the communion of the
other bishops, and suspension from the performance of clerical functions.
Bright.
This canon is the third of those which were originally proposed by Marcian in the end
of the sixth session, as certain articles for which synodical sanction was desirable (see above
Canons iij. and iv.). It was after they had been delivered by the Emperor’s own hand to
Anatolius of Constantinople that the Council broke out into plaudits, one of which is suffi-
ciently startling, τῷ ἱερεῖ, τῷ βασιλεῖ (Mansi, vii., 177). The imperial draft is in this case
very slightly altered. A reference is made to a previous determination (i.e., canon x.) against
clerical pluralities, and it is ordered that “clerics registered as belonging to one church shall
not be ranked as belonging to the church of another city, but must be content with the one
in which they were originally admitted to minister, excepting those who, having lost their
own country, have been compelled to migrate to another church,”—an exception intelligible
enough at such a period. Eleven years before, the Vandal Gaiseric had expelled the Catholic
283
bishops and priests of Western Africa from their churches: Quodvultdeus, bishop of Carthage
with many of his clergy, had been “placed on board some unseaworthy vessels,” and yet,
“by the Divine mercy, had been carried safe to Naples” (Vict. Vitens., De Persec. Vandal.,
i., 5: he mentions other bishops as driven into exile). Somewhat later, the surge of the
Hunnish invasion had frightened the bishop of Sirmium into sending his church vessels to
Attila’s Gaulish secretary and had swept onward in 447 to within a short distance of the
“New Rome” (Hodgkin, Italy and her Invaders, ii., 54–56). And the very year of the Council
was the most momentous in the whole history of the “Barbaric” movement. The bishops
who assembled in October at Chalcedon must have heard by that time of the massacre of
Canon XX.
523
Canon XX.