which things had induced them to convene and to select defenders, there follows the note
of the universality, which, as the great proposition, is expanded with many proof texts from
the Old and the New Testament. This truth is to be defended against the Donatist assertion
that the universal Church had perished through contamination with Cæcilian; for the Church
is a mixed society of good and evil, and not to be condemned on this account, but its unity
is to be preserved by toleration. If they maintain this view, the documents concerning Cæ-
cilian’s character must be examined. The contestants must prove that the Church was thus
defiled, or else the evil do not defile the good in this unity. The mandate then gives Scrip-
tural and also post-apostolic proofs on this point, especially from Cyprian, and quotes the
Donatist action concerning the Maximianists. The next topic is baptism as a sacrament of
Christ and not of man, and as independent of the character of the celebrant: the Maximian
schism again affords material for the confutation of this Donatistic tenet. They are instructed
also to use the archives to show that their opponents initiated civil appellation.
In the session of the second day, Augustin is the speaker, mainly on the matter of delay
and adjournment.
In the third session, he appears as the chief disputant on the doctrinal and historical
points, and also as answering the letter of the Donatists in reply to the mandate.
In a sermon preached after the close of the Conference, (Sermo ccclix. on Ecclus. xxv.
2), he exhorted all Christians to be brethren; the Catholics desire to have the Donatists unite
with them in worship in the universal Church. The history of Cæcilian should not affect
the doctrine of the body. He claims a triumph indeed for his side and rejoices over the many
who are returning to the mother Church, but candidly confesses that many harden themselves
in their opposition. His exordium appeals for a restoration of brotherly harmony.
A little later in the year, probably, Augustin preached from Gal. vi. 2–5 (Sermo clxiv.),
in which he rebukes those who say: "We are saints, we do not carry your burdens, therefore
we do not communicate with you;"and says: "your ancestors carry burdens of separation,
burdens of schism, burdens of heresy, burdens of dissension, burdens of animosity, burdens
of false proofs, burdens of calumnious accusations." In your boast of non-participation in
395
other’s sins, you desert the flock, the threshing-floor and the net. The traditors who had
condemned the absent Cæcilian dissolved connection with the whole world. He reminds
them of the Maximianists; he charges them with breaking the parables, and yet inculcates
patience. The whole sermon indicates that the effect of the conference had been to embitter
both sides.
Another sermon (xcix.) on Luke vii. 36, 50, was also preached about this time, in which
he conceives that the Puristic noli me tangere may develop into a system for sin-pardoning,
and justification and sanctification; the men of the Gesta Collationis are likely to bring about
such a machine religion. Already do they say: if men do not remit sins, then what Christ
says is false as to loosing on earth and in heaven. With this conception of the tendency of
676
An Analysis of Augustin’s Writings Against the Donatists.