make him willing, and obedient to God? It must be owing to a corrupt and ungrateful heart,
if the riches of divine bounty, in bestowing life and prosperity, things comfortable and
pleasant, will not engage the heart to God and virtue, love and obedience. Whereas he must
always have the rod held over him, be often chastised, and held under the apprehensions of
death, to keep him from running wild in pride, contempt, and rebellion; ungratefully using
the blessings dealt forth from God’s hand, in sinning against him, and serving his enemies.
If man has no natural disingenuity of heart, it must be a mysterious thing indeed, that the
sweet blessings of God’s bounty have not as powerful an influence to restrain him from
sinning against God, as terrible afflictions. If any thing can be a proof of a perverse and vile
disposition, this must be a proof of it, that men should be most apt to forget and despise
God, when his providence is most kind; and that they should need to have God chastising
them with great severity, and even killing them, to keep them in order. If we were as much
disposed to gratitude to God for his benefits, as we are to anger at our fellow-creatures for
injuries, as we must be (so far as I can see) if we are not of a depraved heart; then the
sweetness of divine bounty, and the height of every enjoyment pleasing to innocent human
nature, would be as powerful incentives to a proper regard for God—tending as much to
promote religion and virtue—as to have the world filled with calamities, and to have God
(to use the language of Hezekiah, Isaiah xxviii. 13. describing death and its agonies) as a lion,
breaking all our bones, and from day even to night, making an end of us.
Dr. T. himself (p. 252.) says, “that our first parents before the fall were placed in a con-
dition proper to engage their gratitude, love, and obedience.” Which is as much as to say,
a condition proper to engage them to the exercise and practice of all religion. And if the
paradisaical state was proper to engage to all religion and duty, and men still come into the
world with hearts as good as the two first of the species, why is it not proper to engage them
to it still? What need of so vastly changing man’s state, depriving him of all those blessings,
and instead of them allotting to him a world full of briers and thorns, affliction, calamity,
and death, to engage him to it? The taking away of life, and all those pleasant enjoyments
man had at first, by a permanent constitution, would be no stated benefit to mankind, unless
there was in them a stated disposition to abuse such blessings. The taking of them away, is
supposed to be a benefit, under the notion of their tending to lead men to sin: but they would
have no such tendency, at least in a stated manner, unless there was in men a fixed tendency
to make that unreasonable misimprovement of them. Such a temper of mind, as amounts
to a disposition to make such a misimprovement of blessings, is often spoken of in Scripture
as most astonishingly vile and perverse. So concerning Israel abusing the blessings of Canaan,
that land flowing with milk and honey; their ingratitude in it is spoken of by the prophets,
as enough to astonish all heaven and earth, and as more than brutish stupidity and vile-
ness.Jer. ii. 7. “I brought them into a plentiful country, to eat the fruit thereof, and the
goodness thereof. But when ye entered, ye defiled my land,” &c. See the following verses,
1011
CHAPTER II. Arguments from universal Mortality.