Here, Sir, you seem to suppose that a person’s doubting of his own good estate, is the
proper opposite of faith, and these and some other expressions in your letter seem to suppose
that doubting of one’s good estate and unbelief is the same thing, and so, that being confident
of one’s good estate and faith are the same thing. This I acknowledge I don’t understand; I
don’t take faith, and a person’s believing that they have faith, to be the same thing. Nor do
I take unbelief, or being without faith, and doubting whether they have it, to be the same
thing, but entirely different. I should have been glad either that you had taken a little more
notice of what. I say on this head, p. 76, 77. or that you had said something to convince me
that I am wrong in this point. The exercise of faith is doubtless the way to be delivered from
darkness, deadness, backsliding, &c. or rather is the deliverance; as forsaking sin is the way
to deliverance from sin, and is the deliverance itself. The exercise of grace is doubtless the
way to deliverance from a graceless frame, that consists in the want of the exercise of grace.
But as to what you say, or seem to intimate, of a person’s being confident of his own good
estate, as being the way to be delivered from darkness, deadness, backsliding, and prevailing
iniquity, I think, whoever supposes this to be God’s method of delivering his saints, when
sunk into an evil, careless, carnal, and unchristian frame, first to assure them of their good
estate and his favour, while they yet remain in such a frame, and to make that the means of
their deliverance, does surely mistake God’s method of dealing with such persons. Among
all the multitudes I have had opportunity to observe, I never knew one dealt with after this
manner. I have known many brought back from great declension, that appeared to me to
be true saints, but it was in a way very diverse from this. In the first place, conscience has
been awakened, and they have been brought into great fear of the wrath of God, having his
favour hid, and they have been the subjects of a kind of new work of humiliation, brought
to a great sense of their deserving of God’s wrath, even while they have yet feared it, before
God has delivered them from the apprehension of it, and comforted them with a renewed
sense of his favour.
As to what I say of the necessity of universal obedience, or of one way of known sin, (i.
e. so as properly to be said to be the way and manner of the man,) being exception enough
against a man’s salvation; I should have known better what to have said further about it, if
you had briefly shown how the scriptures that I mention, and the arguments I deduce from
them, are insufficient for the proof of this point. I confess they appear to me to prove it as
fully as any thing concerning the necessary qualifications of a true saint can be proved from
Scripture.
You object against my saying, p. 276. “Nor can a true saint ever fall away, so that it shall
come to this, that ordinarily there shall be no remarkable difference in his walk and behaviour
since his conversion, from what was before.” This, I think, implies no more than that his
walk over the same ground, in like circumstances, and under like trials, will have a remarkable
difference. As to the instance you mention of David and Solomon, I don’t know that the
1484
LETTER I. To Mr. Gillespie, in answer to objections.