VIII.—St. Basil and Eustathius.
It was Basil’s doom to suffer through his friendships. If the fault lay with himself in the
case of Gregory, the same cannot be said of his rupture with Eustathius of Sebaste. If in this
connexion fault can be laid to his charge at all, it was the fault of entering into intimacy with
an unworthy man. In the earlier days of the retirement in Pontus the austerities of Eustath-
ius outweighed in Basil’s mind any suspicions of his unorthodoxy.207 Basil delighted in his
society, spent days and nights in sweet converse with him, and introduced him to his
mother and the happy family circle at Annesi.208 And no doubt under the ascendency of
Basil, Eustathius, always ready to be all things to all men who might be for the time in power
and authority, would appear as a very orthodox ascetic. Basil likens him to the Ethiopian
of immutable blackness, and the leopard who cannot change his spots.209 But in truth his
skin at various periods shewed every shade which could serve his purpose, and his spots
shifted and changed colour with every change in his surroundings.210 He is the patristic
Proteus. There must have been something singularly winning in his more than human at-
tractiveness.211 But he signed almost every creed that went about for signature in his life-
time.212 He was consistent only in inconsistency. It was long ere Basil was driven to with-
draw his confidence and regard, although his constancy to Eustathius raised in not a few,
and notably in Theodotus of Nicopolis, the metropolitan of Armenia, doubts as to Basil’s
soundness in the faith. When Basil was in Armenia in 373, a creed was drawn up, in con-
sultation with Theodotus, to be offered to Eustathius for signature. It consisted of the Nicene
confession, with certain additions relating to the Macedonian controversy.213 Eustathius
signed, together with Fronto and Severus. But, when another meeting with other bishops
was arranged, he violated his pledge to attend. He wrote on the subject as though it were
one of only small importance.214 Eusebius endeavoured, but endeavoured in vain, to make
peace.215 Eustathius renounced communion with Basil, and at last, when an open attack
on the archbishop seemed the paying game, he published an old letter of Basil’s to Apollin-
arius, written by “layman to layman,” many years before, and either introduced, or appended,
207 Ep. ccxiii. § 3. He had been in early days a disciple of Arius at Alexandria.
208 Id. § 5.
209 Ep. cxxx. § 1.
210 cf. Ep. ccxliv. § 9. Fialon, Et. Hist. 128.
211 Ep. ccxii. § 2. cf. Newman, Hist. Sketches, iii. 20.
212 Ep. ccxliv. § 9.
213 Epp. cxxi., ccxliv.
214 Ep. ccxliv.
215 Ep. cxxviii.
St. Basil and Eustathius.
41
St. Basil and Eustathius.