still better from their contraries. For we find ungenerate set against generate, and we under-
stand the indestructible by its opposition to the destructible, and being by contrast with that
which has no subsistence. For as that which was not generated is called ungenerate, and
that which is not destructible is called indestructible, so that which is not non-existent we
call being, and, conversely, as we do not call the generate ungenerate, nor the destructible
indestructible, so that which is non-existent we do not call being. Being, then, is discernible
in the being this or that, goodness or indestructibility in the being of this or of that kind,
generacy or ungeneracy in the manner of the being. And thus the ideas of being, manner,
and quality are distinct from each other.
But it will be well, I think, to pass over his nauseating observations (for such we must
term his senseless attacks on the method of conception), and dwell more pleasurably on the
subject matter of our thought. For all the venom that our disputant has disgorged with the
view of overthrowing our Master’s speculations in regard to conception, is not of such a
kind as to be dangerous to those who come in its way, however stupid they may be and liable
to be imposed on. For who is so devoid of understanding as to think that there is anything
in what Eunomius says, or to see any ingenuity in his artifices against the truth when he
takes our Master’s reference to corn (which he meant simply by way of illustration, thereby
providing his hearers with a sort of method and introduction to the study of higher instances),
and applies it literally to the Lord of all? To think of his assertion that the most becoming
cause for God’s begetting the Son was His sovereign authority and power, which may be
said not only in regard to the universe and its elements, but in regard to beasts and creeping
things; and of our reverend theologian teaching that the same is becoming in our conception
of God the Only-begotten—or again, of his saying that God was called ungenerate, or
Father, or any other name, even before the existence of creatures to call Him such, as being
afraid lest, His name not being uttered among creatures as yet unborn, He should be ignorant
or forgetful of Himself, through ignorance of His own nature because of His name being
unspoken! To think, again, of the insolence of his attack upon our teaching; what acrimony,
what subtlety does he display, while attempting to establish the absurdity of what he (Basil)
said, namely that He Who was in a manner the Father before all worlds and time, and all
sensitive and intellectual nature, must somehow wait for man’s creation in order to be named
by means of man’s conception, not having been so named, either by the Son or by any of
the intelligent beings of His creation! Why no one, I imagine, can be so densely stupid as
to be ignorant that God the Only-begotten, Who is in the Father1166, and Who seeth the
Father in Himself, is in no need of any name or title to make Him known, nor is the mystery
of the Holy Spirit, Who searcheth out the deep things of God1167, brought to our knowledge
1166 S. John xiv. 9
1167 1 Cor. ii. 10.
544
Answer to Eunomius' Second Book.