shake the resolution of Pammachius himself, and so he sends a secret commission of instruc-
tion.
382
The coercive measures yielded fruit, and the question about the status of recedent
Donatist clergy now became pressing. Augustin had already met with a certain Theodore
on this subject, and in a letter addressed to him [Ep. lxi.] c. 401, recapitulated the proposition
then agreed upon, to be used as a basis for treatment with all who wanted to come over.
The Catholic church opposed only the schism and the rebaptism among the Donatists; what
was good she was ready to acknowledge. Baptism itself, ordination, self-denial, celibacy,
doctrinal views, especially as to the Trinity, these were confessedly right, only to reap the
profit of them, it was essential for Donatists to be in the unity and in the root.
The Council of Carthage of September 13, 401, adopted this view, Can. 2. There had
also been a remarkable scarcity of Catholic clergy, so that application had been made to
Rome and Milan for relief; probably this had its influence upon so charitable a view of
schismatic ordination.
It was alleged that Crispinus, the bishop of Calama, had bought a state farm at Mappalia,
and had rebaptized the tenants. Augustin was roused by this counter-irritant and wrote
him a letter, c. 402 A.D. [Ep. lxvi.], wondering what he would do if the authorities were to
impose the fine for every offense. He pleads for an answer to Christ, whose was all the world,
because bought with his blood, while the Donatist would affirm that Christ had lost all the
world save Africa. He urges a public discussion of the mooted points before these converts,
which should be reported and done into Punic as a test of their freedom in this conversion,
and frankly enough offers to do the same for any case of coercion on his side. Unless
Crispinus and his helpers acquiesce, he will hold them guilty.
The uppermost talk of those times was the extraordinary charity of the Donatists toward
the Maximianists. One form of apology for such a seeming vacation of all their tenets was
to say, e.g., of Felicianus of Musti, that he was ignorantly condemned when innocent and
absent, so in his absence, he was reinstated. This statement was made by a Donatis bishop,
Clarentius, in reply to the inquiries of Naucelio. Alypius and Augustin, who were made
aware of this defense, urged in criticism [Ep. lxx.] that the Council of Bagai was therefore
guilty in condemning Felicianus unheard, and all the more in that they afterward found
him to be innocent. Either he ought not to have been condemned if he was innocent, or if
guilty, he ought not to have been received back. If the council erred, why not apply such a
liability to error to the origin of the schism; might not Cæcilian, unheard, have been con-
demned although innocent? But, as a matter of fact, Felicianus was found guilty while in
thorough and declared sympathy with Maximian, and the state was called upon to enforce
his ejection. If he was welcomed without rebaptism, why not treat the Church diffused
through the whole world with the same consideration?
660
An Analysis of Augustin’s Writings Against the Donatists.