Not only are bishops prohibited from changing their cities, and passing from a smaller
to a larger one, but also from passing from one province to another in which there are
bishops, for the sake of doing any ecclesiastical work there unless they are called by the
bishops of that province.
On the phrase “if it pleases you” the following from St. Athanasius is much to the point
(cit. by Pusey, Councils, p. 143). “They [i.e., the Council of Nice] wrote concerning Easter,
‘It seemed good’ as follows: for it did then seem good, that there should be a general com-
pliance; but about the faith they wrote not ‘It seemed good,’ but ‘Thus believes the Catholic
Church’; and thereupon they confessed how the faith lay, in order to shew that their senti-
ments were not novel, but apostolic.”
Tillemont.
This form is very strong to shew that it was a right which the Pope had not had hitherto.
Van Espen.
Peter de Marca (De Concordia Sacerdotii et Imperii, Lib. VII., Cap. iij., § 8) says that
Hosius here proposed to the fathers to honour the memory of St. Peter that he might the
more easily lead them to consent to this new privilege; for, as De Marca has proved, the
right here bestowed upon the Roman Pontiff was clearly unknown before.
It has been urged that the mention of the pope by name, intimates clearly that the pro-
vision of these canons of an appeal to Rome was of a purely temporary character; and some
famous authors such as Edmund Richer, of the Sorbonne, have written in defence of this
view, but Hefele quotes with great force the words of the learned Protestant, Spittler (Critical
Examination of the Sardican Decisions, Spittler, Sämmtlichen Werken, P. viij., p. 129 sq.).
418
Spittler.
It is said that these Sardican decisions were simply provisional, and intended for the
present necessity; because Athanasius, so hardly pressed by the Arians, could only be rescued
by authorizing an appeal to the Bishop of Rome for a final judgment. Richer, in his History
of the General Councils, has elaborately defended this opinion, and Horix also has declared
in its favour. But would not all secure use of the canons of the councils be done away with
if this distinction between provisional and permanent synodal decisions were admitted? Is
there any sure criterion for distinguishing those canons which were only to be provisional,
from the others which were made for all future centuries? The Fathers of the Synod of
Sardica express themselves quite generally; is it not therefore most arbitrary on our part to
insert limitations? It is beyond question that these decisions were occasioned by the very
critical state of the affairs of Athanasius; but is everything only provisional that is occasioned
by the circumstances of individuals? In this way the most important of the ancient canons
might be set aside.
Hefele.
765
Canon III.