ἀγένητος denies the creation, and ἀγέννητος the generation or parentage. Both are used at
a very early date; e.g. ἀγένητος by Parmenides in Clem. Alex. Strom. v. 14, and by Agothon
in Arist. Eth. Nic. vii. 2 (comp. also Orac. Sibyll. prooem. 7, 17); and ἀγέννητος in Soph.
Trach. 61 (where it is equivalent to δυσγενῶν. Here the distinction of meaning is strictly
preserved, and so probably it always is in Classical writers; for in Soph. Trach. 743 we should
after Porson and Hermann read ἀγένητον with Suidas. In Christian writers also there is
no reason to suppose that the distinction was ever lost, though in certain connexions the
words might be used convertibly. Whenever, as here in Ignatius, we have the double ν
where we should expect the single, we must ascribe the fact to the indistinctness or incor-
rectness of the writer’s theological conceptions, not to any obliteration of the meaning of
the terms themselves. To this early father for instance the eternal γέννησις of the Son was
not a distinct theological idea, though substantially he held the same views as the Nicene
fathers respecting the Person of Christ. The following passages from early Christian writers
will serve at once to show how far the distinction was appreciated, and to what extent the
Nicene conception prevailed in ante-Nicene Christianity; Justin Apol. ii. 6, comp. ib. § 13;
Athenag. Suppl. 10 (comp. ib. 4); Theoph. ad. Aut. ii. 3; Tatian Orat. 5; Rhodon in Euseb.
H. E. v. 13; Clem. Alex. Strom. vi. 7; Orig. c. Cels. vi. 17, ib. vi. 52; Concil. Antioch (a.d. 269)
in Routh Rel. Sacr. III., p. 290; Method. de Creat. 5. In no early Christian writing, however,
is the distinction more obvious than in the Clementine Homilies, x. 10 (where the distinction
is employed to support the writer’s heretical theology): see also viii. 16, and comp. xix. 3,
4, 9, 12. The following are instructive passages as regards the use of these words where the
opinions of other heretical writers are given; Saturninus, Iren. i. 24, 1; Hippol. Hær. vii. 28;
Simon Magus, Hippol. Hær. vi. 17, 18; the Valentinians, Hippol. Hær. vi. 29, 30; the
Ptolemæus in particular, Ptol. Ep. ad. Flor. 4 (in Stieren’s Irenæus, p. 935); Basilides, Hippol.
Hær. vii. 22; Carpocrates, Hippol. Hær. vii. 32.
From the above passages it will appear that Ante-Nicene writers were not indifferent
to the distinction of meaning between the two words; and when once the orthodox Christo-
logy was formulated in the Nicene Creed in the words γεννηθέντα οὐ ποιηθέντα, it became
henceforth impossible to overlook the difference. The Son was thus declared to be γεννητός
but not γενητός. I am therefore unable to agree with Zahn (Marcellus, pp. 40, 104, 223, Ign.
von Ant. p. 565), that at the time of the Arian controversy the disputants were not alive to
the difference of meaning. See for example Epiphanius, Hær. lxiv. 8. But it had no especial
interest for them. While the orthodox party clung to the homousiosas enshrining the doctrine
for which they fought, they had no liking for the terms ἀγέννητος and γεννητός as applied
to the Father and the Son respectively, though unable to deny their propriety, because they
were affected by the Arians and applied in their own way. To the orthodox mind the Arian
47
Excursus on the Words .”