was said to man: "Earth thou art and into earth thou shalt go."257 For from this very fact
we are all so born, because we are earth, and from the fact that we are all so born because
we are earth, we shall all go into earth on account of the desert of the sins of the first man.
But on account of the grace of God, which frees us from the law of sin and of death, having
been converted to righteousness we are freed; so that afterwards this same flesh tortures us
with its punishment so long as we remain in sins, is subjected to us in resurrection, and
shakes us by no adversity from keeping the law of God and His precepts. Whence, since I
have replied to your questions, deign to reply as I desire, how it can happen, that if nature
is contrary to God, sin should be imputed to us, who were sent into that nature not volun-
tarily, but by God Himself, whom nothing could injure?
Fortunatussaid: Just as also the Lord said to His disciples: "Behold I send you as sheep
in the midst of wolves."258 Hence it must be known that not with hostile intent did our
Saviour send forth His lambs, that is His disciples, into the midst of wolves, unless there
had been some contrariety, which He would indicate by the similitude of wolves, where also
He had sent His disciples; that the souls which perchance might be deceived in the midst
of wolves might be recalled to their proper substance. Hence also may appear the antiquity
of our times to which we return, and of our years, that before the foundation of the world
souls were sent in this way against the contrary nature, that subjecting the same by their
passion, victory might be restored to God. For the same apostle said, that not only there
should be a struggle against flesh and blood, but also against principalities and powers, and
the spiritual things of wickedness, and the domination of darkness."259 If therefore in both
places evils dwell and are esteemed wickednesses, not only now is evil in our bodies, but in
the whole world, where souls appear to dwell, which dwell beneath yonder heaven and are
fettered.
23. Augustin said: The Lord sent His lambs into the midst of wolves, that is, just men
into the midst of sinners for the preaching of the gospel received in the time of man from
the inestimable divine Wisdom, that He might call us from sin to righteousness. But what
the apostle says, that our struggle is not against flesh and blood, but against principalities
and powers, and the other things that have been quoted, this signifies that the devil and his
angels, as also we, have fallen and lapsed by sin, and have secured possession of earthly
things, that is, sinful men, who, as long as we are sinners, are under their yoke, just as when
we shall be righteous, we shall be under the yoke of righteousness; and against them we have
a struggle, that passing over to righteousness we may be freed from their dominion. Do
257 Gen. iii. 19.
258 Matt. x. 16.
259 Eph. v. 12.
203
Disputation of the Second Day.