nothing contrary to truth or of his own invention,398 he says that these men were called
Therapeutæ and the women that were with them Therapeutrides.399 He then adds the
Therapeuten und ihre Stellung in der Gesch. der Askese (Strassburg, 1879), proved (what had been asserted already
by Grätz and Jost) that the Therapeutæ are really to be identified with Christian monks, and that the work De
Vita Contemplativa is not a genuine work of Philo’s. If the former proposition is proved, the latter follows of
necessity, for it is absolutely impossible to suppose that monasticism can have existed in so developed a form
(or indeed in any form) in the time of Philo. On the other hand it may be proved that the work is not Philonic,
and yet it may not follow that the Therapeutæ are to be identified with Christian monks. And so some scholars
reject the Philonic authorship while still maintaining the Jewish character of the Therapeutæ (e.g. Nicolas,
Kuenen, and Weingarten; see Schürer, Gesch. der Juden im Zeitalter Jesu Christi, p. 863). In the opinion of the
writer, who agrees therein with the great majority of scholars, Lucius has conclusively demonstrated both his
propositions, and has shown that the work De Vita Contemplativa is the production of some Christian of the
latter part of the third century, who aimed to produce an apology for and a panegyric of monasticism as it existed
in his day, and thus to secure for it wider recognition and acceptance. Lucius concludes with the following words:
“Wir haben es demnach in D.V.C. mit einer Tendenzschrift zu thun, welche, da sie eine weit ausgebildete und
in zahlreichen Ländern verbreitete Askese, so wie Zustände voraussetzt, genau wie dieselben nur im Christenthum
des dritten Jahrhunderts vorhanden waren, kaum anders aufgefasst werden kann, als eine, etwa am Ende des
dritten Jahrhunderts, unter dem Namen Philo’s, zu Gunsten der Christlichen Askese, verfasste Apologie, als
erstes Glied eines an derartigen Producte überaus reichen Litteratur-zweige der alten Kirche.” Compare with
Lucius’ work the reviews of it by Hilgenfeld in the Zeitschrift für wiss. Theol., 1880, pp. 423–440, and by Schürer
in the Theologische Literaturzeitung, 1880, No. 5. The latter especially has added some important considerations
with reference to the reasons for the composition of this work under the name of Philo. Assuming then the
correctness of Lucius’ conclusions, we see that Eusebius was quite right in identifying the Therapeutæ with the
Christian monks as he knew them in his day, but that he was quite wrong in accepting the Philonic authorship
of the work in question, and in concluding that the institution of monasticism as he knew it existed already in
the apostolic age (compare note 19, below).
398 It may fairly be doubted whether the work does not really contain considerable that is not in strict accord-
ance with the facts observed by the author, whether his account is not to an extent idealized, and whether, in
his endeavor to emphasize the Jewish character of the Therapeutæ, with the design of establishing the antiquity
of monasticism (compare the review of Schürer referred to above), he has not allowed himself to introduce some
imaginative elements. The strong asseveration which he makes of the truthfulness of his account would rather
increase than allay this suspicion, and the account itself at certain points seems to bear it out. On the whole,
however, it may be regarded as a reasonably accurate sketch. Were it not such, Eusebius would not have accepted
it, so unreservedly as he does, as an account of Christian monks. Lucius’ exhibition of the points of similarity
between the practices of the Therapeutæ, as described here, and of early Christian monks, as known from other
sources, is very interesting (see p. 158 sq.).
399 θεραπευταί and θεραπευτρίδες, “worshipers” or “physicians”; from θεραπεύω, which means either to do
service to the gods, or to tend the sick.
205
Philo's Account of the Ascetics of Egypt.