Church a system of material, supernatural things, which offered themselves for man’s use.”
(Hist. Dogma. Vol. iv., p. 328.)
Much has been written, and truly written, of the superiority of the iconoclastic rulers;
but when all has been said that can be, the fact still remains, that they were most of them
but sorry Christians, and the justice of the Protestant Archbishop of Dublin’s summing up
of the matter will not be disputed by any impartial student. He says, “No one will deny that
with rarest exceptions, all the religious earnestness, all which constituted the quickening
power of a church, was ranged upon the other [i.e. the orthodox] side. Had the Iconoclasts
triumphed, when their work showed itself at last in its true colours, it would have proved
to be the triumph, not of faith in an invisible God, but of frivolous unbelief in an incarnate
Saviour.” (Trench. Mediæval History, Chap. vii.)
We come now to consider what reception the Seventh of the General Councils met with
in the West. And first we find that it was accepted, so far at least as its dogmatic decrees
went, by the Pope, the whole Roman Church and, so far as we know, by all the West except
the realm of Charlemagne and, as would naturally be expected, the English Church.
It is true that this was a large and very important exception; so large and so important
that it becomes necessary to examine in detail the causes which led to this rejection.
Some persons have supposed that the English council held at Calcuth in 787 rejected
the ecumenical character of II. Nice, because in two of its canons (the 1st and the 4th) it
only speaks of “the faith of the Six General Councils.” But it is evident that the reason for
this was that it had not yet heard of the Nicene synod; moreover such action would have
been clearly impossible, since the council was presided over by the Bishop of Ostia, the
legate of Pope Hadrian.
The first opposition to the council in the West was made apparently by Charlemagne
577
himself. Pope Hadrian sent him a translation of the acts into Latin and signified his accept
ance of the council. But this translation was so badly done that not only was a large part of
the acts utterly unintelligible, but also, in at least one place, a bishop of the council was made
to say that the sacred images were to be adored with the same supreme worship as is paid
to the Holy Trinity.
It may not be wholly charitable to suggest the possibility of such a thing having any in-
fluence in the matter. On the other hand it would be unfair to the reader not to state that
Charlemagne had, or thought that he had, serious grievances against the Empress Irene,
and that he might not have been sorry to have discovered some reason for which to reject
her council. It should, moreover, be remembered how much the Pope in his struggle for
independence of the Eastern Empire trusted to Charlemagne, and therefore how reluctant
he might readily have been to break with so important an ally; and so might be induced to
tolerate the rejection by the Frankish Emperor of what had been received by him, the Vicar
of Christ and the successor of Peter, as the Seventh Ecumenical Synod of the Catholic Church.
1064
Excursus on the Reception of the Seventh Council.