Here I desire the reader to observe, that the word positive is used in two senses. (1.)
Sometimes it is put in opposition to doubtful or uncertain: and then it signifies the same as
certain, peremptory, or assured. But, (2.) The word positive is very often used in a very dif-
ferent sense; not in opposition to doubtful, but in opposition to negative: and so understood,
it signifies very much the same as real or actual. Thus, we often speak of a negative good,
and a positive good. A negative good is a mere negation or absence of evil; but a positive good
is something more,—some real, actual good, instead of evil. So there is a negative charity,
and a positive charity. A negative charity is a mere absence of an ill judgment of a man, or
forbearing to condemn him. Such a charity a man may have towards any stranger he transi-
ently sees in the street, that he never saw or heard any thing of before. A positive charity is
something further than merely not condemning, or not judging ill, it implies a good thought
489
of a man. The reader will easily see that the word positive, taken in this sense, is an exceeding
different thing from certain or peremptory. A man may have something more than a mere
negative charity towards another, or a mere forbearing to condemn him, he may actually
entertain some good thought of him, and yet there may be no proper peremptoriness, no
pretence of any certainty in the case.
Now it is in this sense I use the phrase positive judgment, viz. In opposition to a mere
negative charity; as I very plainly express the matter, and particularly and fully explain myself
in stating the question. In my inquiry (p. 5.) I have the following words: “By christian judg-
ment, I intend something further than a kind of mere negative charity, implying that we
forbear to censure and condemn a man, because we do not know but that he may be godly,
and therefore forbear to proceed on the foot of such a censure or judgment in our treatment
of him; as we would kindly entertain a stranger, not knowing but, in so doing, we entertain
an angel, or precious saint of God: but I mean a positive judgment, founded on some positive
appearance or visibility, some outward manifestation that ordinarily renders the thing
probable. There is a difference between suspending our judgment, or forbearing to condemn,
or having some hope that possibly the thing may be so, and so hoping the best, and a positive
judgment in favour of a person. For having some hope, only implies, that a man is not in
utter despair of a thing; though his prevailing opinion may be otherwise, or he may suspend
his opinion.
Here, I think, my meaning is very plainly and carefully explained. However, inasmuch
as the word positive is sometimes used for peremptory or certain, Mr. W. catches at the term,
and lays fast hold of the advantage he thinks this gives him, and is abundant, all over his
book, in representing as though I insisted on a positive judgment in this sense. So he applies
the word, referring to my use of it, from time to time. Thus, (p. 69. b.) “If there be any thing
in this argument, I think it must be what I have observed, viz. That a Christian must make
a positive judgment and determination, that another man is a saint, and this judgment must
have for its ground something which he supposes is, at least ordinarily, a certain evidence
1905
SECTION II. Degrees of evidence.