Chapter 39.—92. Petilianus said: "But there is no fellowship of darkness with light, nor
any fellowship of bitterness with the sweet of honey; there is no fellowship of life with death,
of innocence with guilt, of water with blood; the lees have no fellowship with oil though
they are related to it as being its dregs, but everything that is reprobate will flow away. It is
the very sink of iniquity; according to the saying of John, ‘They went out from us, but they
were not of us; for if they had been of us, they would no doubt have continued with us.’2103
There is no gold among their pollution: all that is precious has been purged away. For it is
written, ‘As gold is tried in the furnace, so also are the just tried by the harassing of tribula-
tion.’2104 Cruelty is not a part of gentleness, nor religion a part of sacrilege; nor can the
party of Macarius2105 in any way be part of us, because he pollutes the likeness of our rite.
For the enemy’s line, which fills up an enemy’s name, is no part of the force to which it is
opposed; but if it is truly to be called a part, it will find a suitable motto in the judgment of
Solomon, ‘Let their part be cut off from the earth.’"2106
93. Augustin answered: What is it but sheer madness to utter these taunts without
proving anything? You look at the tares throughout the world, and pay no heed to the
wheat, although both have been bidden to grow together throughout the whole of it. You
look at the seed sown by the wicked one, which shall be separated in the time of harvest,2107
and you pay no heed to the seed of Abraham, in which all nations of the earth shall be
blessed.2108 Just as though you were already a purged mass, and virgin honey, and refined
oil, and pure gold, or rather the very similitude of a whited wall. For, to say nothing of your
other faults, do the drunken form a portion of the sober, or are the covetous reckoned among
the portion of the wise? If men of gentle temper appropriate the term of light, where shall
the madness of the Circumcelliones be esteemed to be, excepting in the darkness? Why
then is baptism, given by men like these, held valid among you, and the same baptism of
Christ not held valid, by whatsoever men it may be administered throughout the world?
You see, in fact, that you are separated from the communion of the whole world in so far
as this, that you are not indeed all drunk, nor all of you covetous, nor all men of violence,
but that you are all heretics, and, in virtue of this, are all impious and all sacrilegious.
2103 1 John ii. 19.
2104 Apparently from Wisd. iii. 6.
2105 Macarius acted as imperial commissioner with Paulus, c. 348, to settle the disputes between Donatists
and Catholics, but only to the further exasperation of the former, who accused him of intrusion and murder,
and thereafter called their opponents Macarians.
2106 Prov. ii. 22.
2107 Matt. xiii. 24-30.
2108 Gen. xxii. 18.
Chapter 39
1073
Chapter 39