Chapter 3.—4. Let us therefore, seeing that we adhere to the example of Cyprian, go
on now to consider Cyprian’s Council. What says Cyprian? "Ye have heard," he says, "most
beloved colleagues, what Jubaianus our fellow-bishop has written to me, consulting my
moderate ability concerning the unlawful and profane baptism of heretics, and what answer
I gave him,—giving a judgment which we have once and again and often given, that heretics
coming to the Church ought to be baptized and sanctified with the baptism of the Church.
Another letter of Jubaianus has likewise been read to you, in which, agreeably to his sincere
and religious devotion, in answer to our epistle, he not only expressed his assent, but returned
thanks also, acknowledging that he had received instruction."1265 In these words of the
blessed Cyprian, we find that he had been consulted by Jubaianus, and what answer he had
given to his questions, and how Jubaianus acknowledged with gratitude that he had received
instruction. Ought we then to be thought unreasonably persistent if we desire to consider
this same epistle by which Jubaianus was convinced? For till such time as we are also con-
vinced (if there are any arguments of truth whereby this can be done), Cyprian himself has
established our security by the right of Catholic communion.
5. For he goes on to say: "It remains that we severally declare our opinion on this same
subject, judging no one, nor depriving any one of the right of communion if he differ from
us."1266 He allows me, therefore, without losing the right of communion, not only to con-
tinue inquiring into the truth, but even to hold opinions differing from his own. "For no
one of us," he says, "setteth himself up as a bishop of bishops, or by tyrannical terror forces
his colleagues to a necessity of obeying." What could be more kind? what more humble?
Surely there is here no authority restraining us from inquiry into what is truth. "Inasmuch
as every bishop," he says, "in the free use of his liberty and power, has the right of forming
his own judgment, and can no more be judged by another than he can himself judge anoth-
er,"—that is, I suppose, in those questions which have not yet been brought to perfect
clearness of solution; for he knew what a deep question about the sacrament was then oc-
cupying the whole Church with every kind of disputation, and gave free liberty of inquiry
to every man, that the truth might be made known by investigation. For he was surely not
438
uttering what was false, and trying to catch his simpler colleagues in their speech, so that,
when they should have betrayed that they held opinions at variance with his, he might then
propose, in violation of his promise, that they should be excommunicated. Far be it from
a soul so holy to entertain such accursed treachery; indeed, they who hold such a view about
such a man, thinking that it conduces to his praise, do but show that it would be in accordance
with their own nature. I for my part will in no wise believe that Cyprian, a Catholic bishop,
a Catholic martyr, whose greatness only made him proportionately humble in all things, so
1265 See above, II. ii. 3.
1266 See above, II. ii. 3.
Chapter 3
756
Chapter 3