Chapter 30.—What Kind of Things Even Their Worshippers Have Owned They Have
Thought About the Gods of the Nations.
Cicero the augur laughs at auguries, and reproves men for regulating the purposes of
life by the cries of crows and jackdaws.182 But it will be said that an academic philosopher,
who argues that all things are uncertain, is unworthy to have any authority in these matters.
In the second book of his De Natura Deorum,183 he introduces Lucilius Balbus, who, after
showing that superstitions have their origin in physical and philosophical truths, expresses
his indignation at the setting up of images and fabulous notions, speaking thus: “Do you
not therefore see that from true and useful physical discoveries the reason may be drawn
away to fabulous and imaginary gods? This gives birth to false opinions and turbulent errors,
and superstitions well-nigh old-wifeish. For both the forms of the gods, and their ages, and
clothing, and ornaments, are made familiar to us; their genealogies, too, their marriages,
kinships, and all things about them, are debased to the likeness of human weakness. They
are even introduced as having perturbed minds; for we have accounts of the lusts, cares,
and angers of the gods. Nor, indeed, as the fables go, have the gods been without their wars
and battles. And that not only when, as in Homer, some gods on either side have defended
two opposing armies, but they have even carried on wars on their own account, as with the
Titans or with the Giants. Such things it is quite absurd either to say or to believe: they are
utterly frivolous and groundless.” Behold, now, what is confessed by those who defend the
gods of the nations. Afterwards he goes on to say that some things belong to superstition,
but others to religion, which he thinks good to teach according to the Stoics. “For not only
the philosophers,” he says, “but also our forefathers, have made a distinction between super-
stition and religion. For those,” he says, “who spent whole days in prayer, and offered sac-
rifice, that their children might outlive them, are called superstitious.”184 Who does not
see that he is trying, while he fears the public prejudice, to praise the religion of the ancients,
and that he wishes to disjoin it from superstition, but cannot find out how to do so? For if
those who prayed and sacrificed all day were called superstitious by the ancients, were those
81
also called so who instituted (what he blames) the images of the gods of diverse age and
distinct clothing, and invented the genealogies of gods, their marriages, and kinships?
When, therefore, these things are found fault with as superstitious, he implicates in that
fault the ancients who instituted and worshipped such images. Nay, he implicates himself,
who, with whatever eloquence he may strive to extricate himself and be free, was yet under
the necessity of venerating these images; nor dared he so much as whisper in a discourse to
the people what in this disputation he plainly sounds forth. Let us Christians, therefore,
182 De Divin.ii. 37.
183 Cic. De Nat. Deorum, lib. ii. c. 28.
184 Superstition, from superstes. Against his etymology of Cicero, see Lact. Inst. Div. iv. 28.
What Kind of Things Even Their Worshippers Have Owned They Have Thought About the Gods of the Nations.
200
What Kind of Things Even Their Worshippers Have Owned They Have Thought…