all the Lord’s miracles because they were unusual? They really happened, and their appear-
ance, as seen by men, was true, and not an illusion; and when they are said to be contrary
to nature, it is not that they oppose nature, but that they transcend the method of nature to
which we are accustomed. May God keep the minds of His people who are still babes in
Christ from being influenced by Faustus, when he recommends as a duty that we should
acknowledge Christ’s birth to have been illusory and not real, that so we may end our dispute!
Nay, verily, rather let us continue to contend for the truth against them, than agree with
them in falsehood.
3. But if we are to end the controversy by saying this, why do not our opponents
themselves say it? While they assert the death of Christ to have been not real but feigned,
why do they make out that He had no birth at all, not even of the same kind as His death?
If they had so much regard for the authority of the evangelist as to oblige them to admit
that Christ suffered, at least in appearance, it is the same authority which testifies to His
birth. Two evangelists, indeed, give the story of the birth;1013 but in all we read of Jesus
having a mother.1014 Perhaps Faustus was unwilling to make the birth an illusion, because
the difference of the genealogies given in Matthew and Luke causes an apparent discrepancy.
But, supposing a man ignorant, there are many things also relating to the passion of Christ
in which he will think the evangelists disagree; suppose him instructed, he finds entire
agreement. Can it be right to feign death, and wrong to feign birth? And yet Faustus will
have us acknowledge the birth to be feigned, in order to put an end to the dispute. It will
appear presently in our reply to another objection what we think to be the reason why
Faustus will not admit of any birth, even a feigned one.
4. We deny that there is anything disgraceful in the bodies of saints. Some members,
indeed, are called uncomely, because they have not so pleasing an appearance as those
constantly in view.1015 But attend to what the apostle says, when from the unity and harmony
of the body he enjoins charity on the Church: "Much more those members of the body,
which seem to be feeble, are necessary: and those members of the body, which we think to
be less honorable, upon these we bestow more abundant honor; and our uncomely parts
have more abundant comeliness. For our comely parts have no need: but God hath tempered
the body together, having given more abundant honor to that part which lacked: that there
should be no schism in the body."1016 The licentious and intemperate use of those members
is disgraceful, but not the members themselves; for they are preserved in purity not only by
1013 Matt. i. 25; Luke ii. 7.
1014 Matt. ii. 11; Mark iii. 32; Luke ii. 33; John ii. 1.
1015 In the Retractations, ii. sec 7, Augustin refers in correction of this remark to his Reply to the Second
Answer of Julian, iv. sec. 36, where he makes uncomeliness the effect of sin.
1016 1 Cor. xii. 22-25.
558
Faustus seeks to justify the docetism of the Manichæans. Augustin insists…