Chapter IV.
As it has been shown that he who injures another for the sake of his own advantage will
undergo terrible punishment at the hand of his own conscience, it is referred that nothing
is useful to one which is not in the same way useful to all. Thus there is no place among
Christians for the question propounded by the philosophers about two shipwrecked persons,
for they must show love and humility to all.
24. Hence we infer601 that a man who guides himself according to the ruling of nature,
so as to be obedient to her, can never injure another. If he injures another, he violates nature,
nor will he think that what he has gained is so much an advantage as a disadvantage. And
what punishment is worse than the wounds of the conscience within? What judgment harder
than that of our hearts, whereby each one stands convicted and accuses himself of the injury
that he has wrongfully done against his brother? This the Scriptures speak of very plainly,
saying: “Out of the mouth of fools there is a rod for wrong-doing.”602 Folly, then, is con-
demned because it causes wrong-doing. Ought we not rather to avoid this, than death, or
loss, or want, or exile, or sickness? Who would not think some blemish of body or loss of
inheritance far less than some blemish of soul or loss of reputation?
25. It is clear, then,603 that all must consider and hold that the advantage of the individual
is the same as that of all, and that nothing must be considered advantageous except what is
for the general good. For how can one be benefited alone? That which is useless to all is
harmful. I certainly cannot think that he who is useless to all can be of use to himself. For
if there is one law of nature for all, there is also one state of usefulness for all. And we are
bound by the law of nature to act for the good of all. It is not, therefore, right for him who
wishes the interests of another to be considered according to nature, to injure him against
the law of nature.
26. For if those who run in a race604 are, as one hears, instructed and warned each one
to win the race by swiftness of foot and not by any foul play, and to hasten on to victory by
running as hard as they can, but not to dare to trip up another or push him aside with their
hand, how much more in the course of this life ought the victory to be won by us, without
falseness to another and cheating?
27. Some ask605 whether a wise man ought in case of a shipwreck to take away a plank
from an ignorant sailor? Although it seems better for the common good that a wise man
rather than a fool should escape from shipwreck, yet I do not think that a Christian, a just
601 Cic. de Off. III. 5, § 25.
602 Prov. xiv. 3.
603 Cic. de Off. III. 6.
604 Cic. de Off. III. 10, § 42.
605 Cic. de Off. 23, § 89.
Chapter IV. As it has been shown that he who injures another for the sake of his own advantage will undergo terrible punishment at the hand of his own conscience, it is referred that nothing is useful to one which is not in the same way useful to all. Thus there is no place among Christians for the question propounded by the philosophers about two shipwrecked persons, for they must show love and humility to all.
188
Chapter IV. As it has been shown that he who injures another for the sake…