Chapter 8.—The Festival of the Birth-Day of Manichæus.
9. In adding the words, "by the providence of God the Father," what else did Manichæus
design but that, having got the name of Jesus Christ, whose apostle he calls himself, and of
God the Father, by whose providence he says he was sent by the Son, we should believe
himself, as the Holy Spirit, to be the third person? His words are: "Manichæus, an apostle
of Jesus Christ, by the providence of God the Father." The Holy Spirit is not named, though
He ought specially to have been named by one who quotes to us in favor of his apostleship
the promise of the Paraclete, that he may prevail upon ignorant people by the authority of
the gospel. In reply to this, you of course say that in the name of the Apostle Manichæus
we have the name of the Holy Spirit, the Paraclete, because He condescended to come into
Manichæus. Why then, I ask again, should you cry out against the doctrine of the Catholic
Church, that He in whom divine Wisdom came was born of a virgin, when you do not
scruple to affirm the birth by ordinary generation of him in whom you say the Holy Spirit
came? I cannot but suspect that this Manichæus, who uses the name of Christ to gain access
to the minds of the ignorant, wished to be worshipped instead of Christ Himself. I will state
briefly the reason of this conjecture. At the time when I was a student of your doctrines, to
133
my frequent inquiries why it was that the Paschal feast of the Lord was celebrated generally
with no interest, though sometimes there were a few languid worshippers, but no watchings,
no prescription of any unusual fast,—in a word, no special ceremony,—while great honor
is paid to your Bema, that is, the day on which Manichæus was killed, when you have a
platform with fine steps, covered with precious cloth, placed conspicuously so as to face the
votaries,—the reply was, that the day to observe was the day of the passion of him who really
suffered, and that Christ, who was not born, but appeared to human eyes in an unreal
semblance of flesh, only feigned suffering, without really bearing it. Is it not deplorable,
that men who wish to be called Christians are afraid of a virgin’s womb as likely to defile
the truth, and yet are not afraid of falsehood? But to go back to the point, who that pays
attention can help suspecting that the intention of Manichæus in denying Christ’s being
born of a woman, and having a human body, was that His passion, the time of which is now
a great festival all over the world, might not be observed by the believers in himself, so as
to lessen the devotion of the solemn commemoration which he wished in honor of the day
of his own death? For to us it was a great attraction in the feast of the Bema that it was held
during Pascha, since we used all the more earnestly to desire that festal day [the Bema], that
the other which was formerly most sweet had been withdrawn.
The Festival of the Birth-Day of Manichæus.
217
The Festival of the Birth-Day of Manichæus.