APPENDIX.
Being a letter to the author, in answer to his request of information concerning the opinion
of Protestant Divines and Churches in general, of the Presbyterians in Scotland and Dissenters
in England in particular, respecting five questions that relate to this controversy.
rev. and dear sir,
If you look into Mr. Baxter’s controversial writings against Mr. Blake, you will meet
with such accounts of principles and facts, as I think may reasonably give an inquirer much
satisfaction as to the common judgment of protestant churches and divines in the points
you mention. I particularly refer you to his five disputations of Right to Sacraments, and the
true Nature of Visible Christianity; where all or the most of your queries are considered and
answered, with a multitude of testimonies produced in favour of sentiments contrary to
those of your excellent predecessor, the late Mr. Stoddard. I have not said this from any
disposition to excuse myself from the labour of making some further inquiry, if it be thought
needful. And as it may show my willingness to gratify your desire, I will now say something
on your questions distinctly, but with as much brevity as I can.
Quest. I. What is the general opinion respecting that self-examination required in 1 Cor.
xi. 28. Whether communicants are not here directed to examine themselves concerning the
truth of grace, or their real godliness?
Answ. This construction of the text, as far as I have had opportunity to inquire, appears
to me very generally received; if I may judge by what many celebrated expositors have said
on the place, and by what many famous divines have written in treatises of preparation for
the Lord’s supper, besides what is contained in public confessions, catechisms, directories,
&c. I think Dr. Reynolds, in his Meditations on the Lord’s Supper, has summarily expressed
the common judgment of Calvinists in these strong lines of his: “The sacrament is but a seal
of the covenant; and the covenant essentially includes conditions; and the condition on our
part is faith. No faith, no covenant; no covenant, no seal; no seal, no sacrament.—The matter
then of this trial (says he) must be that vital qualification, which predisposeth a man for
receiving of these holy mysteries; and that is faith.“
However, I may venture to be confident, that Mr. Stoddard’s gloss on the text, who tells
us in his controverted sermon, “The meaning is, that a man must come solemnly to that or-
dinance, examining what need he has of it,“ is quite foreign from the current sense of
Calvinist writers. And, though he makes a different comment in his Appeal to the Learned,
saying, “The examination called for is, whether they understood the nature of the ordinance,
that so they may solemnly consider what they have to do when they wait upon God in it,”
neither can I find any appearance of a general consent of the learned and orthodox to this
new gloss, at least as exhibiting the full meaning of the text. I might easily confront it with
numerous authorities: but the Palatine Catechism, and that of the Westminster Assembly,
with the common explanations and catechizings upon them, may be appealed to as instar
Appendix. Mr. Foxcroft's letter.
1879
Appendix. Mr. Foxcroft's letter.