and others that had no existence, and that he gave them barbarous names in order to amaze
those who marvel at such things; that he taught also that the eating of meat offered to idols
and the unguarded renunciation of the faith in times of persecution were matters of indif-
ference;1028 and that he enjoined upon his followers, like Pythagoras, a silence of five
years.1029
8. Other similar things the above-mentioned writer has recorded concerning Basilides,
and has ably exposed the error of his heresy.
9. Irenæus also writes1030 that Carpocrates was a contemporary of these men, and that
he was the father of another heresy, called the heresy of the Gnostics,1031 who did not wish
as quoted by Clement, occurs a reference to the prophecy of Cham or Ham. Rienstra (De Euseb. Hist. Eccles. p.
29) thinks that Agrippa Castor was mistaken in saying that Basilides mentioned these prophets; but there seems
to be no good reason to deny the accuracy of the report, even though we know nothing more about the prophets
mentioned. Hort (Dict. of Christ. Biog., article Barcabbas) thinks it likely that the prophecies current among the
various Gnostic bodies belonged to the apocryphal Zoroastrian literature.
1028 This was not a doctrine of Basilides himself, but of his followers (compare the accounts of Irenæus and
Hippolytus). If Agrippa Castor represented Basilides’ position thus, as Eusebius says he did (though Eusebius
may be only following Irenæus), it is an evidence that he did not live at the early date to which Eusebius assigns
him, and this goes to confirm the view stated above, in note 10. Basilides himself taught at least a moderate as-
ceticism, while his followers went off into crude dualism and moral license (see the excellent account of Schaff,
Ch. Hist. II. 466 sq.).
1029 Exactly what is meant by this “five years of silence” is uncertain. Whether it denoted unquestioning and
silent obedience of all commands, as it meant in the case of the Pythagoreans (if, indeed, the traditions in regard
to the latter have any basis in fact), or strict secrecy as to the doctrines taught, cannot be decided. The report in
regard to the Basilidians, in so far as it has any truth, probably arose on the ground of some such prohibition,
which may have been made by some follower of Basilides, if not by the latter himself. A bond of secrecy would
lend an air of mystery to the school, which would accord well with the character of its later teachings. But we
cannot make Basilides responsible for such proceedings. Agrippa Castor, as reproduced here by Eusebius, is
our sole authority for the enjoinment of silence by Basilides.
1030 See Irenæus, Adv. Hær. I. 25.
1031 The date of the rise of Gnosticism cannot be fixed. Indeed, all the requisite conditions existed from the
beginning. It was the “acute Verweltlichung” (as Harnack calls it) of Christianity, the development of it in con-
nection with the various ethnic philosophies, and it began as soon as Christianity came in contact with the Greek
mind. At first it was not heretical, simply because there were no standards by which to try it. There was only
the preaching of the Christians; the canon was not yet formed; episcopacy was not yet established; both arose
as safeguards against heresy. It was in the time of Hadrian, perhaps, that these speculations began to be regarded
as heresies, because they contradicted certain fundamental truths to which the Christians felt that they must
cling, such as the unity of God, his graciousness, his goodness, etc.; and therefore the Christians dated Gnosticism
from that time. Gnosticism was ostensibly conquered, but victory was achieved only as the Church itself became
393
The Persons that became at that Time Leaders of Knowledge falsely so-ca…