into being without passivity and action concurring to produce it, how can our author think
that he here abides by his own words? seeing that, in declaring community of essence to be
involved in the relation of action and passion, he seems not only to attest in some sense
community of essence in Him that is begotten with Him that begat Him, but also to make
the whole creation of one essence644 with its Maker, if, as he says, the active and the passive
are to be defined as mutually akin in respect of nature. Thus, by the very arguments by which
he establishes what he wishes, he overthrows the main object of his effort, and makes the
glory of the coessential Son more secure by his own contention. For if the fact of origination
from anything shows the essence of the generator to be in the generated, and if artificial
fabrication (being accomplished by means of action and passion) reduces both that which
makes and that which is produced to community of essence, according to his account, our
author in many places of his own writings maintains that the Lord has been begotten. Thus
by the very arguments whereby he seeks to prove the Lord alien from the essence of the
Father, he asserts for Him intimate connexion. For if, according to his account, separation
in essence is not observed either in generation or in fabrication, then, whatever he allows
the Lord to be, whether “created” or a “product of generation,” he asserts, by both names
alike, the affinity of essence, seeing that he makes community of nature in active and passive,
in generator and generated, a part of his system.
Let us turn however to the next point of the argument. I beg my readers not to be impa-
tient at the minuteness of examination which extends our argument to a length beyond
what we would desire. For it is not any ordinary matters on which we stand in danger, so
that our loss would be slight if we should hurry past any point that required more careful
attention, but it is the very sum of our hope that we have at stake. For the alternative before
us is, whether we should be Christians, not led astray by the destructive wiles of heresy, or
whether we should be completely swept away into the conceptions of Jews or heathen. To
the end, then, that we may not suffer either of these things forbidden, that we may neither
agree with the doctrine of the Jews by a denial of the verily begotten Son, nor be involved
in the downfall of the idolaters by the adoration of the creature, let us perforce spend some
time in the discussion of these matters, and set forth the very words of Eunomius, which
run thus:—
“Now as these things are thus divided, one might reasonably say that the most proper
and primary essence, and that which alone exists by the operation of the Father, admits for
itself the appellations of ‘product of generation,’ ‘product of making,’ and ‘product of cre-
ation’:” and a little further on he says, “But the Son alone, existing by the operation of the
644 ὁμοούσιον
307
He proceeds again to discuss the impassibility of the Lord's generation;…