Let me also refer to Bledsoe’s most solemn and searching reply to John Foster; also to
his answer to Lord Kames’s effort to help the Lord out of a supposed difficulty. 4073 I am
sorry that Tillotson exposed himself to a witty retort by the same author, in these words:
“If the Almighty really undertook to deceive the world for its own good, it is a pity He did
not take the precaution to prevent the archbishop from detecting the cheat,…not suffering
his secret to get into the possession of one who has so indiscreetly published it.” The awful
importance of the subject, and the recently awakened interest in its discussion, have led me
to enlarge this annotation.
4073 Theodicy, pp. 295–311 (answer to Foster), p. 81 (to Lord Kames), p. 310 (to Tillotson). I must confess
that Bledsoe is paulo iniquior when he gives no reference to Tillotson’s language. If the retort is based on the
sermon (xxxv. vol. iii. p. 350, ed. folio, 1720) on the “Eternity of Torment,” however, I do not think it just. The
latitudinarian primate restricts himself therein to a very guarded statement of that reserved right by which any
governor commutes or remits punishment, though he cannot modify a promise of reward. I wish modern
apologists for the divine sovereignty had not gone farther.
1241
Elucidation.