45. On receipt of this letter, Diodorus made himself master of its contents, and then
entered the lists against Manes. This he did too with such spirit, that he was commended
greatly by all for the careful and satisfactory demonstration which he gave of the fact that
there is a mutual relationship between the two testaments, and also between the two laws.1996
Discovering also more arguments for himself he was able to bring forward many points of
great pertinency and power against the man, and in defence of the truth. He also reasoned
in a conclusive manner against his opponent on verbal grounds.1997 For example, he argued
with him in the following manner:—Did you say that the testaments are two? Well, then,
say either that there are two old testaments, or that there are two new testaments. For you
assert that there are two unbegottens1998 belonging to the same time, or rather eternity: and
if there are in this way two, there should be either two old testaments or two new testaments.
If, however, you do not allow this, but affirm, on the contrary, that there is one old testament
and that there is also another new testament, that will only prove again that there is but one
author for both; and the very sequence will show that the Old Testament belongs to Him
221
to whom also the New Testament pertains. We may illustrate this by the case of a man who
says to some other individual,1999 Lease me your old house. For by such a mode of address
does he not pronounce the man to be also the owner of a new house? Or, on the other hand,
if he says to him, Show me2000 your new house; does he not by that very word designate
him also as the possessor of an old house? Then, again, this also is to be considered, that
since there are two beings, having an unbegotten nature, it is also necessary from that to
suppose each of them to have (what must be called) an old testament, and thus there will
appear to be two old testaments; if indeed you affirm that both these beings are ancient, and
both indeed without a beginning.2001 But I have not learned doctrine like that; neither do
the Scriptures contain it. You, however, who allege that the law of Moses comes from the
prince of evil, and not from the good God, tell me who those were who withstood Moses to
the face—I mean Jamnes and Mambres?2002 For, every object that withstands, withstands
1996 [See p. 215, supra.]
1997 Ex nominibus. The Codex Bobiensis offers the extraordinary reading, ex navibus.
1998 Ingenita.
1999 We read, with the Codex Bobiensis, “dicat homini, Loca mihi,” etc. The Codex Casinensis has the
meaningless reading, “homini diviti,” etc.
2000 Præsta.
2001 The text of this obscure passage runs thus: “Quia ex quo duo sunt, ingenitam habentes naturam, ex eo
necesse est etiam habere unumquemque ipsorum vetus Testamentum, et fient duo vetera Testamenta; si tamen
ambos antiquos et sine initio esse dicis.” The Codex Bobiensis gives a briefer but evidently corrupt reading: “ex
quo duo sunt ingenita habentes naturam ipsorum Testamentum, et fient,” etc.
2002 Jamnem dico et Mambrem. [So in Vulg., except “Jannes.”]
Chapter XLV.
520
Chapter XLV.