Jerome and
Gennadius.
Lives of Illustrious
Men.
————————————
I. Introduction.
This
combined work of Jerome and Gennadius is unique and indispensable
in the history of early Christian literature, giving as it does a
chronological history in biographies of ecclesiastical literature to
about the end of the fifth century. For the period after the end of
Eusebius’ Church History it is of prime value.
1.
Time and Place of
Composition, and Character
.
1.
The work of Jerome
was
written at Bethlehem in 492. It contains 135 writers from Peter up to
that date. In his preface Jerome limits the scope of his work to those
who have written on Holy Scriptures, but in carrying out his plans he
includes all who have written on theological topics; whether Orthodox
or Heretic, Greek, Latin, Syriac, and even Jews and Heathen (Josephus,
Philo, Seneca). The Syriac writers mentioned are however few. Gennadius
apologizes for the scanty representation which they have in Jerome on
the ground that the latter did not understand Syriac, and only knew of
such as had been translated.
The motive of the work was, as
the preface declares, to show the heretics how many and how excellent
writers there were among the Christians. The direct occasion of the
undertaking was the urgency of his friend Dexter, and his models were
first of all Suetonius, and then various Greek and Latin biographical
works including the
Brutus
of Cicero.
Jerome expressly states in his
preface that he had no predecessor in his work, but very properly
acknowledges his indebtedness to the Church History of Eusebius, from
whom he takes much verbatim. The first part of the work is taken almost
entirely from Eusebius.
The whole work gives evidence of
hasty construction (e.g., in failure to enumerate the works of
well-known writers or in giving only selections from the list of their
writings) but too much has been made of this, for in such work absolute
exhaustiveness is all but impossible, and in the circumstances of those
days, such a list of writers and their works is really remarkable. He
apologizes in the preface for omitting such as are not known to him in
his “Out of the way corner of the earth.” He has been
accused of too great credulity, in accepting e.g., the letters of Paul
to Seneca as genuine, but on the other hand he often shows himself both
cautious (Hilary,
Song of S.
) and critical (Minutius Felix
De
Fato
).
The work was composed with a
practical purpose rather than a scientific one and kept in general well
within that purpose—giving brief information about writers not
generally known. This is perhaps why in writings of the better known
writers like Cyprian he does not enumerate their works.
2.
The work of Gennadius
was written about 430 according to some, or 492 to 495 according to
others. Ebert with the Benedictins and others before him, makes an
almost conclusive argument in favor of the earlier date on the ground
that Gennadius speaks of
Timotheus Aelurus who died in
477 as still living. This compels the rejection of the paragraph on
Gennadius himself as by a later hand but this should probably be done
at any rate, on other grounds. The
mss.
suggest that Gennadius ended with John of Antioch, although an
hypothesis of three editions before the year 500, of which perhaps two
were by Gennadius, has grounds. The bulk of the work at least was
composed about 480 (probably chapters 1–90) and the remainder
added perhaps within a few years by Gennadius or more probably two
other hands.
Gennadius style is as bare and
more irregular than Jerome’s but he more frequently expresses a
critical judgment and gives more interesting glimpses of his
own—the semi-Pelagian—point of view. The work appears more
original than Jerome’s and as a whole hardly less valuable,
though the period he covers is so much shorter.