212 THE SEVEN BOOKS OF [Boox tv.
90. But in the discussion which we at present maintain,
we do not undertake this trouble or service, to show and de-
clare who all these were. [But] this is what we proposed to
ourselves, that as you call us impious and irreligious, [and,]
on the other hand, maintain that you are pious and serve the
gods, we should prove and make manifest that by no men
are they treated with less respect than by you. But if it is
proved by the very insults that it is so, it must, as a conse-
quence, be understood that it is you who rouse the gods to
fierce and terrible rage, because you either listen to or believe,
or yourselves invent about them, stories so degrading. For
it is not he who is anxiously thinking of religious rites,’ and
slays spotless victims, who gives piles of incense to be burned
with fire, not he must be thought to worship the deities, or
alone discharge the duties of religion. "True worship is in
the heart, and a belief worthy of the gods; nor does it at
all avail to bring blood and gore, if you believe about them
things which are not only far remote from and unlike their
nature, but even to some extent stain and disgrace both
their dignity and virtue.
91. We wish, then, to question you, and invite you to
answer a short question, Whether you think it a greater offence
to sacrifice to them no victims, because you think that so
great a being neither wishes nor desires these; or, with foul
beliefs, to hold opinions about them so degrading, that they
might rouse any one's spirit to a mad desire for revenge?
lf the relative importance of the matters be weighed, you
will find no judge so prejudiced as not to believe it a greater
crime to defame by manifest insults any one's reputation,
than to treat it with silent neglect. For this, perhaps, may
be held and believed from deference to reason; [but] the
other course manifests an impious spirit, and a blindness
despaired of in fiction. If in your ceremonies and rites
neglected sacrifices and expiatory offerings may be demanded,
guilt is said to have been contracted; if by a momentary
1 Qui sollicite relegit. Relegit is here used by Arnobius to denote the
root of religio, and has therefore some such meaning as that given above.
Cf. Cicero, de Nat. Deorum, ii. 28