who come to christian sacraments; which is likely speedily to issue in a separation between
cx
me and my congregation. This controversy, in the progress of it, has proved not only a
controversy between me and my people, but between me and a great part of New England;
there being many far and near who are warmly engaged in it. This affair has unavoidably
engaged my mind, and filled up my time, and taken me off from other things. I need the
prayers of my friends, that God would be with me, and direct and assist me in such a time
of trial, and mercifully order the issue.
As to the epistolary controversy, dear Sir, between you and me, about faith and doubting,
I am sorry it should seem to be greater than it is, through misunderstanding of one another’s
meaning, and that the real difference between us is so great as it is, in some part of the
controversy.
As to the dispute about believing without spiritual light or sight, I thought I expressed
my meaning in my last letter very plainly; but I kept no copy, and it might perhaps be owing
to my dulness that I thought so. However, I perceive I was not understood. I cannot find
out by any thing you say to me on this head, that we really differ in sentiments, but only in
words. I acknowledge with you that ‘all are bound to believe the divine testimony, and trust
in Christ; and that want of spiritual light or sight does not loose from the obligation one is
laid under by the divine command, to believe instantly on Christ, and at all seasons, nor
excuse him, in any degree, for not believing. Even when one wants the influence and grace
of the Spirit, still he is bound to believe.’ I think the obligation to believe, lies on a person
who is remaining without spiritual light or sight, or even in darkness. No darkness, no
blindness, no carnality or stupidity, excuses him a moment for not having as strong and
lively a faith and love, as ever was exercised by the apostle Paul, or rather renders it not
sinful in him, that he is at that same moment without such a faith and love;—and yet I believe
it is absurd, and of a very hurtful consequence, to urge persons to believe in the dark, in the
manner, and in the sense, in which many hundreds have done in America, who plainly intend,
a believing with such a sort of strong faith or confidence, as is consistent with continuing
still, even in the time of these strong acts of faith, without spiritual light, carnal, stupid,
careless, and senseless. Their doctrine evidently comes to this, both in sense and effect, that
it is a man’s duty strongly to believe with a lightless and sightless faith; or to have a confident,
although a blind, dark, and stupid faith. Such a faith has indeed been promoted exceedingly
by their doctrine, and has prevailed with its dreadful effects, answerable to the nature of the
cause. We have had, and have to this day, multitudes of such firm believers whose bold,
presumptuous confidence, attended with a very wicked behaviour, has given the greatest
wound to the cause of truth and vital religion, which it has ever suffered in America.
As to what follows in your letter, that a person’s believing himself to be in a good estate
is properly of the nature of faith; in this there seems to be some real difference between us.
But perhaps there would be none, if distinctness were well observed in the use of words. If
224
CHAPTER XV. Arrival of David Brainerd at Northampton. His sickness and…