additional defilement from the flesh of the countless animals that eat the fruit; except, indeed,
the small amount that is purified by your eating it. While we believe and confess Christ the
Son of God, and the Word of God, to have become flesh without suffering defilement, because
the divine substance is not defiled by flesh, as it is not defiled by anything, your fanciful
notions would make Jesus to be defiled even as hanging on the tree, before entering the flesh
of any animal; for if He were not defiled, there would be no need of His being purified by
your eating Him. And if all trees are the cross of Christ, as Faustus seems to imply when
he says that Jesus hangs from every tree, why do you not pluck the fruit, and so take Jesus
down from hanging on the tree to bury Him in your stomach, which would correspond to
the good deed of Joseph of Arimathea, when he took down the true Jesus from the cross to
258
bury Him?740 Why should it be impious to take Christ from the tree, while it is pious to lay
Him in the tomb? Perhaps you wish to apply to yourselves the words quoted from the
prophet by Paul, "Their throat is an open sepulchre:"741 and so you wait with open mouth
till some one comes to use your throat as the best sepulchre for Christ. Once more, how
many Christs do you make? Is there one whom you call the mortal Christ, whom the earth
conceives and brings forth by the power of the Holy Spirit; and another crucified by the
Jews under Pontius Pilate; and a third whom you divide between the sun and the moon?
Or is it one and the same person, part of whom is confined in the trees, to be released by
the help of the other part which is not confined? If this is the case, and you allow that Christ
suffered under Pontius Pilate, though it is difficult to see how he could have suffered without
flesh, as you say he did, the great question is, with whom he left those ships you speak of,
that he might come down and suffer these things, which he certainly could not have suffered
without having a body of some kind. A mere spiritual presence could not have made him
liable to these sufferings, and in his bodily presence he could not be at the same time in the
sun, in the moon, and on the cross. So, then, if he had not a body, he was not crucified; and
if he had a body, the question is, where he got it: for, according to you, all bodies belong to
the race of darkness, though you cannot think of the divine substance except as being ma-
terial. Thus you must say either that Christ was crucified without a body; which is utterly
absurd; or that he was crucified in appearance and not in reality, which is blasphemy; or
that all bodies do not belong to the race of darkness, but that the divine substance has also
a body, and that not an immortal body, but liable to crucifixion and death, which, again, is
altogether erroneous; or that Christ had a mortal body from the race of darkness, so that,
while you will not allow that Christ’s body came from the Virgin Mary, you derive it from
the race of demons. Finally, as in Faustus’ statement, in which he alludes in the briefest
manner possible to the lengthy stories of Manichæan invention, the earth by the power of
740 John xix. 38.
741 Rom. iii. 13.
440
Faustus repels the charge of sun-worship, and maintains that while the Manichæans…