72 THE SEVEN BOOKS OF [ Boox ir.
which you read from time to time on subjects placed beyond
human knowledge? Does not each one trust this author or
that? That which any one has persuaded himself is said
with truth by another, does he not defend with a kind of
assent, as it were, [like that] of faith? Does not he who
says that fire! or water is the origin of all things, pin his
faith to Thales or Heraclitus? he who places the cause [of
all] in numbers, to Pythagoras of Samos, [and] to Archytas?
he who divides the soul, and sets up bodiless forms, to Plato,
the disciple of Socrates? he who adds a fifth element? to the
primary causes, to Aristotle, the father of the Peripatetics?
he who threatens the world with [destruction by] fire, and
says that when the time comes it will be [set] on fire, to
Panetius, Chrysippus, Zeno? he who is always fashioning
worlds from atoms, and destroying [them], to Epicurus,
Democritus, Metrodorus? he who [says] that nothing is com-
prehended by man, and that all things are wrapt in dark
obscurity to Archesilas? to Carneades?—to some teacher,
in fine, of the old and later Academy ?
10. Finally, do not even the leaders and founders of the
schools? already mentioned, say those very things? which
1 “Fire” is wanting in the Ms.
? Arnobius here allows himself to be misled by Cicero (Tusc. i. 10),
who explains évreagyese as a kind of perpetual motion, evidently con-
fusing it with évdcagyese (cf. Donaldson, New Crat. S 339 sqq.), and re-
presents Aristotle as making it a fifth primary cause. The word has no
such meaning, and Aristotle invariably enumerates only four primary
causes: the material from which, the form in which, the power by which,
and the end for which anything exists (Physics, ii. 3; Pur er iv. 2, etc.).
3 Lit., ** with indivisible bodies." TIL
5 So Us MS., LB., and Hildebrand, reading Archesile, while the
others read Archesilao, forgetting that Arcesilas is the regular Latin
form, although Archesilaus is found.
$ Sententiarum is read in the first ed. by Gelenius, Canterus, and
Ursinus, and seems from Crusius to be the ws. reading. The other
edd., however, have received from the margin of Ursinus the reading of
the text, sectarum.
7 [n the first ed., and that of Ursinus, the reading is, nonne apud ea,
** jn those things which they say, do they not say,” etc., which Gelenius
emended as in the text, nonne ipsa ea.