but the reader cannot fail to recognise their great and varied value, the completeness of his
refutation of current heresies, the convincing character of his presentation of the truth, and
the originality, restrained always by scrupulous reverence as well as by intellectual caution,
of his additions to the speculative development of the Faith. We recognise also the tenacity
with which, encumbered as he was with the double task of simultaneously refuting Arianism
and working out his own thoughts, he has adhered to the main issues. He never wanders
into details, but keeps steadfastly to his course. He refrains, for instance, from all consider-
ation of the results which Arianism might produce upon the superstructure of the Faith and
upon the conduct of Christians; they are undermining the foundations, and he never forgets
that it is these which he has undertaken to strengthen and defend. Our confidence in him
as a guide is increased by the eminently businesslike use which he makes of his higher
qualities. This is obvious in the smallest details, as, for instance, in his judicious abstinence,
which will be considered in the next chapter, from the use of technical terms of theology,
when their employment would have made his task easier, and might even, to superficial
minds, have enhanced his reputation. We see it also in the talent which he shews in the
device of watchwords, which serve both to enliven his pages and to guide the reader through
their argument. Such is the frequent antithesis of the orthodox unitas with the heretical
unio, the latter a harmless word in itself and used by Tertullian indifferently with the former,
but seized by the quick intelligence of Hilary to serve this special end99; such also, the frequent
‘Not two Gods but One100,’ and the more obvious contrast between the Catholic unum and
the Arian unus. Thus, in excellence of literary workmanship, in sustained cogency and steady
progress of argument, in the full use made of rare gifts of intellect and heart, we must recog-
nise that Hilary has brought his great undertaking to a successful issue; that the voyage beset
with many perils, to use his favourite illustration, has safely ended in the haven of Truth
and Faith.
Whether the De Trinitate were complete or not at the time of his return to Poitiers, after
the triumphal passage through Italy, its publication in its final form must very shortly have
followed. But literature was, for the present, to claim only the smaller share of his attention.
Heartily as he must have rejoiced to be again in his home, he had many anxieties to face.
The bishops of Gaul, as we saw from the Invective against Constantius, had been less militant
against their Arian neighbours than he had wished. There had been peace in the Church;
such peace as could be produced by a mutual ignoring of differences. And it may well be
that the Gallican bishops, in their prejudice against the East, thought that Hilary himself
had gone too far in the path of conciliation, and that his alliance with the Semiarians was a
much longer step towards compromise with heresy than their own prudent neutrality. Each
99 E.g. iv. 42, fin.
100 E.g. i. 17.
54
The Life and Writings of St. Hilary of Poitiers.