was a direction to them as to what they should attempt, not a prediction of what they should
bring to pass in their day. For they never brought one-half of any one nation into the visible
christian church, nor any at all in one-half of the nations in the world, it is very probable.
If it should be further objected, that it is an evidence that Gentile Christians are visible
saints, according to the New-Testament notion of visible saintship, in the very same manner
as the whole Jewish nation were till they were broken off by their obstinate rejection of the
Messiah; that the Gentile Christians are represented as being grafted into the same olive,
from whence the Jews were broken off by unbelief, Rom. xi. 17, &c.
I would inquire, What any one can intend by this objection? Whether it be this, viz.
That we ought to insist on no higher or better qualifications, in admitting persons as
members of the christian church, and to all its privileges, than the whole Jewish nation in
Christ’s time possessed, till they had obstinately persisted in their rejection of him? If this
is not intended, the objection is nothing to the purpose: or, if this be intended, neither then
is it to the purpose of those with whom I have especially to do in this controversy, who hold
orthodoxy, knowledge of the fundamental doctrines of religion, moral sincerity, and a good
conversation, to be qualifications, which ought to be insisted on, in order to a visible church-
state. For a very great part of those Jews were destitute of these qualifications; many of them
were Sadducees, who denied a future state; others of them Herodians, who were occasional
conformists with the Romans in their idolatries; the prevailing sect among them were
Pharisees, who openly professed the false doctrine of justification by the works of the law
and external privileges, that leaven of the Pharisees, which Christ warns his disciples to beware
of. Many of them were scandalously ignorant, for their teachers had taken away the key of
knowledge. Multitudes were grossly vicious, for it was a generation in which all manner of
sin and wickedness prevailed.
I think that text in Rom. xi.. can be understood no otherwise, in any consistence with
plain fact, than that the Gentile Christians succeeded the Jews, who had been, either in
themselves or ancestors, the children of Abraham, with respect to a visible interest in the
covenant of grace, until they were broken off from the church, and ceased to be visible saints
by their open and obstinate unbelief. Indeed their ancestors had all been thus broken off
from the church of visible saints; for every branch or family of the stock of Jacob had been
in the church of visible saints, and each branch withered and failed through unbelief. This
was the highest and most important sense, in which any of the Jews were externally the
children of Abraham, and implied the greatest privileges. But there was another sense, in
which the whole nation, including even those of them who were no visible saints, were his
children, which (as has been shown) implied great privileges, wherein christian Gentiles do
not succeed them, though they have additional ecclesiastical privileges, vastly beyond the
Jews.
1830
OBJ. II. Israel was God's people.