Another reason why the things mentioned are mistaken for true virtue, is, that there is
indeed a true negative moral goodness in them. By a negative moral goodness, I mean the
negation or absence of true moral evil. They have this negative moral goodness, because
being without them would be an evidence of a much greater moral evil. Thus the exercise
of natural conscience in such and such degrees, wherein appears such a measure of sensib-
ility, though it be not of the nature of real positive virtue, or true moral goodness, yet has a
negativemoral goodness; because in the present state of things, it is an evidence of the absence
of that higher degree of wickedness, which causes great insensibility, or stupidity of con-
science. For sin is not only against a spiritual and divine sense of virtue, but is also against
the dictates of that moral sense which is in natural conscience. No wonder, that this sense,
being long opposed and often conquered, grows weaker. All sin has its source from selfishness,
or from self-love, not subordinate to a regard to being in general. And natural conscience
chiefly consists in a sense of desert, or the natural agreement between sin and misery. But
if self were indeed all, and so more considerable than all the world besides, there would be
no ill desert in a man regarding himself above all, and making all other interests give place
to private interest. And no wonder that men, by long acting from the selfish principle, and
by being habituated to treat themselves as if they were all, increase in pride, and come to
look on themselves as all, and so to lose entirely the sense of ill desert in their making all
other interests give place to their own. And no wonder that any, by often repeating acts of
sin without punishment, or visible appearance of approaching punishment, have less and
less present sense of the connexion of sin with punishment.
That sense which an awakened conscience has of the desert of sin, consists chiefly in a
sense of its desert of resentment from the Deity, the fountain and head of universal existence.
But no wonder that, by a long continued worldly and sensual life, men more and more lose
all sense of the Deity, who is a spiritual and invisible Being. The mind being long involved
in, and engrossed by, sensitive objects, becomes sensual in all its operations, and excludes
all views and impressions of spiritual objects, and is unfit for their contemplation. Thus
conscience and general benevolence, are entirely different principles; and thus a sense of
conscience differs from the holy complacence of a benevolent and truly virtuous heart. Yet
wickedness may by long habitual exercise greatly diminish a sense of conscience. so that
there may be negative moral goodness, in sensibility of conscience, as it may be an argument
of the absence of that higher degree of wickedness, which causeth stupidity of conscience.
So with respect to natural gratitude; though there may be no virtue merely in loving
them that love us, yet the contrary may be an evidence of a great degree of depravity, as it
may argue a higher degree of selfishness, so that a man is come to look upon himself as all,
and others as nothing, and so their respect and kindness as nothing. Thus an increase of
pride diminishes gratitude. So doth sensuality, or the increase of sensual appetites; which,
coming more and more under the power and impression of sensible objects, tends by degrees
911
CHAPTER VII. The reasons of many mistakes