§7.
Continuance of
the Arian Controversy. Eusebius’ Relations to the Two
Parties.
The Council of Nicæa did
not bring the Arian controversy to an end. The orthodox party was
victorious, it is true, but the Arians were still determined, and could
not give up their enmity against the opponents of Arius, and their hope
that they might in the end turn the tables on their antagonists.
Meanwhile, within a few years after the Council, a quarrel broke out
between our Eusebius and Eustathius, bishop of Antioch, a resolute
supporter of Nicene orthodoxy. According to Socrates (
H. E.
I.
23) and Sozomen (
H. E
. II. 18) Eustathius accused Eusebius of
perverting the Nicene doctrines, while Eusebius denied the charge, and
in turn taxed Eustathius with Sabellianism. The quarrel finally became
so serious that it was deemed necessary to summon a Council for the
investigation of Eustathius’ orthodoxy and the settlement of the
dispute. This Council met in Antioch in 330
a.d.
(see Tillemont, VII. p. 651 sq., for a discussion of
the date), and was made up chiefly of bishops of Arian or semi-Arian
tendencies. This fact, however, brings no discredit upon Eusebius. The
Council was held in another province, and he can have had nothing to do
with its composition. In fact, convened, as it was, in
Eustathius’ own city, it must have been legally organized; and
indeed Eustathius himself acknowledged its jurisdiction by appearing
before it to answer the charges made against him. Theodoret’s
absurd account of the origin of the synod and of the accusations
brought against Eustathius (
H. E.
I. 21) bears upon its face the
stamp of falsehood, and is, as Hefele has shown
(
Conciliengeschichte
, I. 451), hopelessly in error in its
chronology. It is therefore to be rejected as quite worthless. The
decision of the Council doubtless fairly represented the views of the
majority of the bishops of that section, for we know that Arianism had
a very strong hold there. To think of a packed Council and of illegal
methods of procedure in procuring the verdict against Eustathius is
both unnecessary and unwarrantable. The result of the Council was the
deposition of Eustathius from his bishopric and his banishment by the
Emperor to Illyria, where he afterward died. There is a division of
opinion among our sources in regard to the immediate successor of
Eustathius. All of them agree that Eusebius was asked to become bishop
of Antioch, but that he refused the honor, and that Euphronius was
chosen in his stead. Socrates and Sozomen, however, inform us that the
election of Eusebius took place immediately after the deposition of
Eustathius, while Theodoret (
H. E.
I. 22) names Eulalius as
Eustathius’ immediate successor, and states that he lived but a
short time, and that Eusebius was then asked to succeed him. Theodoret
is supported by Jerome (
Chron
., year of Abr. 2345) and by
Philostorgius (
H. E
. III. 15), both of whom insert a bishop
Eulalius between Eustathius and Euphronius. It is easier to suppose
that Socrates and Sozomen may have omitted so unimportant a name at
this point than that the other three witnesses inserted it without
warrant. Socrates indeed implies in the same chapter that his knowledge
of these affairs is limited, and it is not surprising that
Eusebius’ election, which caused a great stir, should have been
connected in the mind of later writers immediately with
Eustathius’ deposition, and the intermediate steps forgotten. It
seems probable, therefore, that immediately after the condemnation of
Eustathius, Eulalius was appointed in his place, perhaps by the same
Council, and that after his death, a few months later, Eusebius, who
had meanwhile gone back to Cæsarea, was elected in due order by
another Council of neighboring bishops summoned for the purpose, and
that he was supported by a large party of citizens. It is noticeable
that the letter written by the Emperor to the Council, which wished to
transfer Eusebius to Antioch (see
Vita Const
. III. 62), mentions
in its salutation the names of five bishops, but among them is only one
(Theodotus) who is elsewhere named as present at the Council which
deposed Eusta
thius, while Eusebius of Nicomedia, and Theognis of Nicæa, as
well as others whom we know to have been on hand on that occasion, are
not referred to by the Emperor. This fact certainly seems to point to a
different council.
It is greatly to Eusebius’
credit that he refused the call extended to him. Had he been governed
simply by selfish ambition he would certainly have accepted it, for the
patriarchate of Antioch stood at that time next to Alexandria in point
of honor in the Eastern Church. The Emperor commended him very highly
for his decision, in his epistles to the people of Antioch and to the
Council (
Vita Const
. III. 60, 62), and in that to Eusebius
himself (
ib
. III. 61). He saw in it a desire on Eusebius’
part to observe the ancient canon of the Church, which forbade the
transfer of a bishop from one see to another. But that in itself can
hardly have been sufficient to deter the latter from accepting the high
honor offered him, for it was broken without scruple on all sides. It
is more probable that he saw that the schism of the Antiochenes would
be embittered by the induction into the bishopric of that church of
Eustathius’ chief opponent, and that he did not feel that he had
a right so to divide the Church of God. Eusebius’ general
character, as known to us, justifies us in supposing that this high
motive had much to do with his decision. We may suppose also that so
difficult a place can have had no very great attractions for a man of
his age and of his peace-loving disposition and scholarly tastes. In
Cæsarea he had spent his life; there he had the great library of
Pamphilus at his disposal, and leisure to pursue his literary work. In
Antioch he would have found himself compelled to plunge into the midst
of quarrels and seditions of all kinds, and would have been obliged to
devote his entire attention to the performance of his official duties.
His own tastes therefore must have conspired with his sense of duty to
lead him to reject the proffered call and to remain in the somewhat
humbler station which he already occupied.
Not long after the deposition of
Eustathius, the Arians and their sympathizers began to work more
energetically to accomplish the ruin of Athanasius, their greatest foe.
He had become Alexander’s successor as bishop of Alexandria in
the year 326, and was the acknowledged head of the orthodox party. If
he could be brought into discredit, there might be hopes of restoring
Arius to his position in Alexandria, and of securing for Arianism a
recognition, and finally a dominating influence in the church at large.
To the overthrow of Athanasius therefore all good Arians bent their
energies. They found ready accomplices in the schismatical Meletians of
Egypt, who were bitter enemies of the orthodox church of Alexandria. It
was useless to accuse Athanasius of heterodoxy; he was too widely known
as the pillar of the orthodox faith. Charges must be framed of another
sort, and of a sort to stir up the anger of the Emperor against him.
The Arians therefore and the Meletians began to spread the most vile
and at the same time absurd stories about Athanasius (see especially
the latter’s
Apol. c. Arian
. §59 sq.). These at last
became so notorious that the Emperor summoned Athanasius to appear and
make his defense before a council of bishops to be held in Cæsarea
(Sozomen,
H. E
. II. 25; Theodoret,
H. E
. I. 28).
Athanasius, however, fearing that the Council would be composed wholly
of his enemies, and that it would therefore be impossible to secure
fair play, excused himself and remained away. But in the following year
(see Sozomen,
H. E
. II. 25) he received from the Emperor a
summons to appear before a council at Tyre. The summons was too
peremptory to admit of a refusal, and Athanasius therefore attended,
accompanied by many of his devoted adherents (see Sozomen,
ib
.;
Theodoret,
H. E
. I. 30; Socrates,
H. E
. I. 28;
Athanasius,
Apol. c. Arian
. §71 sq.; Eusebius,
Vita
Const
. IV. 41 sq., and Epiphanius,
Hær
. LXVIII. 8).
After a time, perceiving that he had no chance of receiving fair play,
he suddenly withdrew from the Council and proceeded directly to
Constantinople, in order to lay his case before the Emperor himself,
and to induce the latter to allow him to meet his accusers in his
presence, and plead his cause before him. There was nothing for the
Synod to do after his flight but to sustain the charges brought against
him, some of which he had not stayed to refute, and to pass
condemnation upon him. Besides various immoral and sacrilegious deeds
of which he was accused, his refusal to appear before the Council
of
Cæsarea the previous year was made an important item of the
prosecution. It was during this Council that Potamo flung at Eusebius
the taunt of cowardice, to which reference was made above, and which
doubtless did much to confirm Eusebius’ distrust of and hostility
to the Athanasian party. Whether Eusebius of Cæsarea, as is
commonly supposed, or Eusebius of Nicomedia, or some other bishop,
presided at this Council we are not able to determine. The account of
Epiphanius seems to imply that the former was presiding at the time
that Potamo made his untimely accusation. Our sources are, most of
them, silent on the matter, but according to Valesius, Eusebius of
Nicomedia is named by some of them, but which they are I have not been
able to discover. We learn from Socrates (
H. E
. I. 28), as well
as from other sources, that this Synod of Tyre was held in the
thirtieth year of Constantine’s reign, that is, between July,
334, and July, 335. As the Council was closed only in time for the
bishops to reach Jerusalem by July, 335, it is probable that it was
convened in 335 rather than in 334. From Sozomen (
H. E
. II. 25)
we learn also that the Synod of Cæsarea had been held the
preceding year, therefore in 333 or 334 (the latter being the date
commonly given by historians). While the Council of Tyre was still in
session, the bishops were commanded by Constantine to proceed
immediately to Jerusalem to take part in the approaching festival to be
held there on the occasion of his
tricennalia
. The scene was one
of great splendor. Bishops were present from all parts of the world,
and the occasion was marked by the dedication of the new and
magnificent basilica which Constantine had erected upon the site of
Calvary (Theodoret, I. 31; Socrates, I. 28 and 33; Sozomen, II. 26;
Eusebius,
Vita Const
. IV. 41 and 43). The bishops gathered in
Jerusalem at this time held another synod before separating. In this
they completed the work begun at Tyre, by re-admitting Arius and his
adherents to the communion of the Church (see Socrates, I. 33, and
Sozomen, II. 27). According to Sozomen the Emperor, having been induced
to recall Arius from banishment in order to reconsider his case, was
presented by the latter with a confession of faith, which was so worded
as to convince Constantine of his orthodoxy. He therefore sent Arius
and his companion Euzoius to the bishops assembled in Jerusalem with
the request that they would examine the confession, and if they were
satisfied with its orthodoxy would re-admit them to communion. The
Council, which was composed largely of Arius’ friends and
sympathizers, was only too glad to accede to the Emperor’s
request.
Meanwhile Athanasius had induced
Constantine, out of a sense of justice, to summon the bishops that had
condemned him at Tyre to give an account of their proceedings before
the Emperor himself at Constantinople. This unexpected, and, doubtless,
not altogether welcome summons came while the bishops were at
Jerusalem, and the majority of them at once returned home in alarm,
while only a few answered the call and repaired to Constantinople.
Among these were Eusebius of Nicomedia, Theognis of Nicæa,
Patrophilus of Scythopolis, and other prominent Arians, and with them
our Eusebius (Athanasius,
Apol. c. Arian
. §§86 and 87;
Socrates, I. 33–35; Sozomen, II. 28). The accusers of Athanasius
said nothing on this occasion in regard to his alleged immoralities,
for which he had been condemned at Tyre, but made another equally
trivial accusation against him, and the result was his banishment to
Gaul. Whether Constantine banished him because he believed the charge
brought against him, or because he wished to preserve him from the
machinations of his enemies (as asserted by his son Constantine, and
apparently believed by Athanasius himself; see his
Apol. c.
Arian
. §87), or because he thought that Athanasius’
absence would allay the troubles in the Alexandrian church we do not
know. The latter supposition seems most probable. In any case he was
not recalled from banishment until after Constantine’s death. Our
Eusebius has been severely condemned by many historians for the part
taken by him in the Eustathian controversy and especially in the war
against Athanasius. In justice to him a word or two must be spoken in
his defense. So far as his relations to Eustathius are concerned, it is
to be noticed that the latter commenced the controversy by accusing
Eusebius of heterodoxy. Eusebius himself did not begin the quarrel, and
very likely had no desire to engage in any such doctrinal strife; but
he was compelled to defend him
self, and in doing so he could
not do otherwise than accuse Eustathius of Sabellianism; for if the
latter was not satisfied with Eusebius’ orthodoxy, which Eusebius
himself believed to be truly Nicene, then he must be leaning too far
toward the other extreme; that is, toward Sabellianism. There is no
reason to doubt that Eusebius was perfectly straightforward and
honorable throughout the whole controversy, and at the Council of
Antioch itself. That he was not actuated by unworthy motives, or by a
desire for revenge, is evinced by his rejection of the proffered call
to Antioch, the acceptance of which would have given him so good an
opportunity to triumph over his fallen enemy. It must be admitted, in
fact, that Eusebius comes out of this controversy without a stain of
any kind upon his character. He honestly believed Eustathius to be a
Sabellian, and he acted accordingly.
Eusebius has been blamed still
more severely for his treatment of Athanasius. But again the facts must
be looked at impartially. It is necessary always to remember that
Sabellianism was in the beginning and remained throughout his life the
heresy which he most dreaded, and which he had perhaps most reason to
dread. He must, even at the Council of Nicæa, have suspected
Athanasius, who laid so much stress upon the unity of essence on the
part of Father and Son, of a leaning toward Sabellianistic principles;
and this suspicion must have been increased when he discovered, as he
believed, that Athanasius’ most staunch supporter, Eustathius,
was a genuine Sabellian. Moreover, on the other side, it is to be
remembered that Eusebius of Nicomedia, and all the other leading
Arians, had signed the Nicene creed and had proclaimed themselves
thoroughly in sympathy with its teaching. Our Eusebius, knowing the
change that had taken place in his own mind upon the controverted
points, may well have believed that their views had undergone even a
greater change, and that they were perfectly honest in their
protestations of orthodoxy. And finally, when Arius himself presented a
confession of faith which led the Emperor, who had had a personal
interview with him, to believe that he had altered his views and was in
complete harmony with the Nicene faith, it is not surprising that our
Eusebius, who was naturally unsuspicious, conciliatory and
peace-loving, should think the same thing, and be glad to receive Arius
back into communion, while at the same time remaining perfectly loyal
to the orthodoxy of the Nicene creed which he had subscribed. Meanwhile
his suspicions of the Arian party being in large measure allayed, and
his distrust of the orthodoxy of Athanasius and of his adherents being
increased by the course of events, it was only natural that he should
lend more or less credence to the calumnies which were so industriously
circulated against Athanasius. To charge him with dishonesty for being
influenced by these reports, which seem to us so absurd and palpably
calumnious, is quite unwarranted. Constantine, who was, if not a
theologian, at least a clear-headed and sharp-sighted man, believed
them, and why should Eusebius not have done the same? The incident
which took place at the Council of Tyre in connection with Potamo and
himself was important; for whatever doubts he may have had up to that
time as to the truth of the accusations made against Athanasius and his
adherents, Potamo’s conduct convinced him that the charges of
tyranny and high-handed dealing brought against the whole party were
quite true. It could not be otherwise than that he should believe that
the good of the Alexandrian church, and therefore of the Church at
large, demanded the deposition of the seditious and tyrannous
archbishop, who was at the same time quite probably Sabellianistic in
his tendencies. It must in justice be noted that there is not the
slightest reason to suppose that our Eusebius had anything to do with
the dishonorable intrigues of the Arian party throughout this
controversy. Athanasius, who cannot say enough in condemnation of the
tactics of Eusebius of Nicomedia and his supporters, never mentions
Eusebius of Cæsarea in a tone of bitterness. He refers to him
occasionally as a member of the opposite party, but he has no
complaints to utter against him, as he has against the others. This is
very significant, and should put an end to all suspicions of unworthy
conduct on Eusebius’ part. It is to be observed that the latter,
though having good cause as he believed to condemn Athanasius and his
adherents, never acted as a leader in the war against them. His name,
if mentioned at all, occurs always toward the end of the list as one
of
the
minor combatants, although his position and his learning would have
entitled him to take the most prominent position in the whole affair,
if he had cared to. He was but true to his general character in
shrinking from such a controversy, and in taking part in it only in so
far as his conscience compelled him to. We may suspect indeed that he
would not have made one of the small party that repaired to
Constantinople in response to the Emperor’s imperious summons had
it not been for the celebration of Constantine’s
tricennalia
, which was taking place there at the time, and at
which he delivered, on the special invitation of the Emperor and in his
presence, one of his greatest orations. Certain it is, from the account
which he gives in his
Vita Constantini
, that both in
Constantinople and in Jerusalem the festival of the
tricennalia
,
with its attendant ceremonies, interested him much more than did the
condemnation of Athanasius.