§16. Examination of the meaning of ‘subjection:’ in that he says that the nature of the
Holy Spirit is subject to that of the Father and the Son. It is shewn that the Holy Spirit is of
an equal, not inferior, rank to the Father and the Son.
Let us first, then, ascertain the meaning of this word ‘subjection’ in Scripture. To whom
is it applied? The Creator, honouring man in his having been made in His own image, ‘hath
placed’ the brute creation ‘in subjection under his feet;’ as great David relating this favour
(of God) exclaimed in the Psalms108: “He put all things,” he says, “under his feet,” and he
mentions by name the creatures so subjected. There is still another meaning of ‘subjection’
in Scripture. Ascribing to God Himself the cause of his success in war, the Psalmist says109,
“He hath put peoples and nations in subjection under our feet,” and “He that putteth peoples
in subjection under me.” This word is often found thus in Scripture, indicating a victory.
As for the future subjection of all men to the Only-begotten, and through Him to the Father,
in the passage where the Apostle with a profound wisdom speaks of the Mediator between
God and man as subject to the Father, implying by that subjection of the Son who shares
humanity the actual subjugation of mankind—we will not discuss it now, for it requires a
full and thorough examination. But to take only the plain and unambiguous meaning of
the word subjection, how can he declare the being of the Spirit to be subject to that of the
Son and the Father? As the Son is subject to the Father, according to the thought of the
Apostle? But in this view the Spirit is to be ranked with the Son, not below Him, seeing that
both Persons are of this lower rank. This was not his meaning? How then? In the way the
brute creation is subject to the rational, as in the Psalm? There is then as great a difference
as is implied in the subjection of the brute creation, when compared to man. Perhaps he
will reject this explanation as well. Then he will have to come to the only remaining one,
that the Spirit, at first in the rebellious ranks, was afterwards forced by a superior Force to
bend to a Conqueror.
Let him choose which he likes of these alternatives: whichever it is I do not see how he
54
can avoid the inevitable crime of blasphemy: whether he says the Spirit is subject in the
manner of the brute creation, as fish and birds and sheep, to man, or were to fetch Him a
captive to a superior power after the manner of a rebel. Or does he mean neither of these
ways, but uses the word in a different signification altogether to the scripture meaning?
What, then, is that signification? Does he lay down that we must rank Him as inferior and
not as equal, because He was given by our Lord to His disciples third in order? By the same
reasoning he should make the Father inferior to the Son, since the Scripture often places
the name of our Lord first, and the Father Almighty second. “I and My Father,” our Lord
says. “The grace of our Lord Jesus Christ, and the love of God110,” and other passages innu-
108 Psalm viii. 6–8.
109 Psalm xlvii. 3 (LXX.).
110 John x. 30; 2 Cor. xiii. 13.
Examination of the meaning of 'subjection:' in that he says that the nature of the Holy Spirit is subject to that of the Father and the Son. It is shewn that the Holy Spirit is of an equal, not inferior, rank to the Father and the Son.
101
Examination of the meaning of 'subjection:' in that he says that the nature…