in the bread, which they call a member of God, the substance of God, and bind it in flesh.
What then do ye? why do ye eat? Have ye not flesh? Yes; but we, they say, forasmuch as we
are enlightened by faith in Manes,5771 by our prayers and our Psalms, forasmuch as we are
elect, we cleanse thereby that bread, and transmit it into the treasure-house of the heavens.
Such are the elect, that they are not to be saved by God, but saviours of God. And this is
Christ, they say, crucified in the whole universe. I received in the Gospel Christ a Saviour,
but ye are in your books the saviours of Christ. Plainly ye are blasphemers of Christ, and
646
therefore not to be saved by Christ. Therefore lest a crumb be given to the hungry, and in
the crumb a member of Christ suffer, is the hungry to die of hunger? False mercy to a crumb
causeth true murder of a man. But who are their elect? “Turn not thou aside, my heart, to
wicked words, and I will not unite with their elect.”
7. “The righteous One shall amend me in mercy, and convict me” (ver. 5). Behold the
sinner confessing. He desireth to be amended in mercy, rather than praised deceit-
fully.…“Shall convict me,” but “in mercy:” shall convict, yet hateth not: yea, shall all the
more convict, because He hateth not. And why doth he therefore give thanks? Because,
“rebuke a wise man, and he will love thee.”5772 “The righteous One shall amend me.” Because
He persecuteth thee? God forbid. He requireth rather amending himself, who amendeth in
hate. Wherefore then doth He amend? “In mercy. And shall convict me.” Wherein? “In
mercy. For the oil of a sinner shall not enrich my head.” My head shall not grow by flattery.
Undue praise is flattery: undue praise of a flatterer is “the oil of a sinner.” Therefore men
too, when they have mocked any one with false praise, say, “I have anointed his head.” Love
then to be “convicted by the righteous One in mercy;” love not to be praised by a sinner in
mockery. Have oil in yourselves, and ye shall not seek the “oil of a sinner.”5773…
8. Thou sayest to me, What am I doing? I am beset with flatterers; they cease not to be-
siege me; they praise in me what I would not, that praise in me what I hold in little esteem;
what I hold dear they blame in me; flatterers, treacherous, deceivers. For instance, “Gaiusei-
us5774 is a great man, great, learned, wise; but why is he a Christian? For great is his learning,
great his reading, great his wisdom.” If great is his wisdom, approve of his being a Christian;
if great his learning, learnedly hath he chosen. In fine, what thou revilest, that pleaseth him
5771 [See Confessions, vol. i. p. 76, note 8, this series; also A.N.F. vol. vi. p. 175.—C.]
5772 Prov. ix. 8.
5773 Matt. xxv. 4, etc.
5774 This is probably taken from Tertullian, Apol. c. 3: “What when the generality run upon an hatred of
this name with eyes so closed, that, in bearing favourable testimony to any one, they mingle with it the reproach
of the name. ‘A good man Cais Seius, only he is a Christian.’ So another, ‘I marvel that that wise man Lucius
Titius hath suddenly become a Christian.’ No one reflected whether Caius be not therefore good and Lucius
wise, because a Christian, or therefore a Christian because wise and good.” [See A.N.F. vol. iii. p. 20.—C.]
1285
Psalm CXLI