211
Book V.
Introduction.
1. Soter,1345 bishop of the church of Rome, died after an episcopate of eight years, and
was succeeded by Eleutherus,1346 the twelfth from the apostles. In the seventeenth year of
the Emperor Antoninus Verus,1347 the persecution of our people was rekindled more fiercely
1345 On Soter, see above, Bk. IV. chap. 19, note 2.
1346 Eusebius in his Chronicle gives the date of Eleutherus’ accession as the seventeenth year of Marcus
Aurelius (177 a.d.), and puts his death into the reign of Pertinax (192), while in chap. 22 of the present book he
places his death in the tenth year of Commodus (189). Most of our authorities agree in assigning fifteen years
to his episcopate, and this may be accepted as undoubtedly correct. Most of them, moreover, agree with chap.
22 of this book, in assigning his death to the tenth year of Commodus, and this too may be accepted as accurate.
But with these two data we are obliged to push his accession back into the year 174 (or 175), which is accepted
by Lipsius (see his Chron. der röm. Bischöfe, p. 184 sq.). We must therefore suppose that he became bishop some
two years before the outbreak of the persecution referred to just below, in the fourteenth or fifteenth year of
Marcus Aurelius. In the Armenian version of the Chron. Eleutherus is called the thirteenth bishop of Rome (see
above, Bk. IV. chap. 19, note 5), but this is a mistake, as pointed out in the note referred to. Eleutherus is men-
tioned in Bk. IV, chap. 11, in connection with Hegesippus, and also in Bk. IV. chap. 22, by Hegesippus himself.
He is chiefly interesting because of his connection with Irenæus and the Gallican martyrs (see chap. 4, below),
and his relation to the Montanistic controversy (see chap. 3). Bede, in his Hist. Eccles., chap. 4, connects
Eleutherus with the origin of British Christianity, but the tradition is quite groundless. One of the decretals and
a spurious epistle are falsely ascribed to him.
1347 i.e., the seventeenth year of the reign of Marcus Aurelius, a.d. 177 (upon Eusebius’ confusion of Marcus
Aurelius with Lucius Verus, see below, p. 390, note). In the Chron. the persecution at Lyons and Vienne is asso-
ciated with the seventh year of Marcus Aurelius (167), and consequently some (e.g. Blondellus, Stroth, and
Jachmann), have maintained that the notice in the present passage is incorrect, and Jachmann has attacked
Eusebius very severely for the supposed error. The truth is, however, that the notice in the Chron. (in the Ar-
menian, which represents the original form more closely than Jenner’s version does) is not placed opposite the
seventh year of Marcus Aurelius (as the notices in the Chron. commonly are), but is placed after it, and grouped
with the notice of Polycarp’s martyrdom, which occurred, not in 167, but in 155 or 156 (see above, Bk. IV. chap.
15, note 2). It would seem, as remarked by Lightfoot (Ignatius, I. p. 630), that Eusebius simply connected together
the martyrdoms which he supposed occurred about this time, without intending to imply that they all took place
in the same year. Similar groupings of kindred events which occurred at various times during the reign of an
emperor are quite common in the Chron. (cf. the notices of martyrdoms under Trajan and of apologies and re-
scripts under Hadrian). Over against the distinct statement of the history, therefore, in the present instance, the
notice in the Chron. is of no weight. Moreover, it is clear from the present passage that Eusebius had strong
grounds for putting the persecution into the time of Eleutherus, and the letter sent by the confessors to
Eleutherus (as recorded below in chap. 4) gives us also good reason for putting the persecution into the time of
Book VIntroduction.
490
Book V