OBJECT. XVI.
You cannot keep out hypocrites, when all is said and done; but as many graceless persons
475
will be likely to get into the church in the way of a profession of godliness, as if nothing were
insisted on, but a freedom from public scandal.
Answ. It may possibly be so in some places through the misconduct of ministers and
people, by remissness in their inquiries, carelessness as to the proper matter of a profession,
or setting up some mistaken rules of judgment; neglecting those things which the Scripture
insists upon as the most essential articles in the character of a real saint; and substituting
others in the room of them; such as impressions on the imagination, instead of renewing
influences on the heart; pangs of affection, instead of the habitual temper of the mind; a
certain method and order of impressions and suggestions, instead of the nature of things
experienced, &c. But to say, that in churches where the nature, the notes, and evidences of
true Christianity, as described in the Scriptures, are well understood, taught, and observed,
there as many hypocrites are likely to get in; or to suppose, that there as many persons of an
honest character, who are well instructed in these rules, and well conducted by them—and
judging of themselves by these rules, do think themselves true saints, and accordingly make
profession of godliness, and are admitted as saints in a judgment of rational charity—are
likely to be carnal, unconverted men, as of those who make no such pretence and have no
such hope, nor exhibit any such evidences to the eye of a judicious charity, is not so much
an objection against the doctrine I am defending, as a reflection upon the Scripture itself,
with regard to the rules it gives, either for persons to judge of their own state, or for others
to form a charitable judgment, as if they were of little or no service. We are in miserable
circumstances indeed, if the rules of God’s holy word in things of such infinite importance,
are so ambiguous and uncertain, like the heathen oracles. And it would be very strange, if
in these days of the gospel, when God’s mind is revealed with such great plainness of speech,
and the canon of Scripture is completed, it should ordinarily be the case in fact, that those
who, having a right doctrinal understanding of the Scripture, and judging themselves by its
rules, do probably conclude or seriously hope of themselves, that they are real saints, are as
many of them in a state of sin and condemnation, as others who have no such rational hope
concerning their good estate, nor pretend to any special experiences in religion.
OBJ. XVI. Hypocrites will be admitted.
1866
OBJ. XVI. Hypocrites will be admitted.