we have had many Christs. And if you say that these were not begotten by the same Holy
Spirit, and yet aver that He had brethren, then without doubt we shall be under the necessity
of understanding that, in succession to the Spirit and after Gabriel, the most pure and
spotless virgin2022 formed an actual marriage connection with Joseph. But if this is also a
thing altogether absurd—I mean the supposition that she had any manner of intercourse
with Joseph—tell me whether then He had brethren. Are you thus to fix the crime of adultery
also on her, most sagacious Marcellus?2023 But if none of these suppositions suits the position
of the Virgin undefiled, how will you make it out that He had brothers? And if you are unable
to prove clearly to us that He had brethren, will it be any the easier for you to prove Mary
to be His mother, in accordance with the saying of him who ventured to write,2024 “Behold,
Thy mother and Thy brethren stand without?” Yet, although that man was bold enough to
address Him thus, no one can be mightier or greater than this same person Himself who
shows us His mother or His brethren. Nay, He does not deign even to hear it said that He
is David’s son.2025 The Apostle Peter, however, the most eminent of all the disciples, was
able to acknowledge Him on that occasion, when all were putting forth the several opinions
which they entertained respecting Him: for he said, “Thou art the Christ, the Son of the
living God;”2026 and immediately He names him blessed, addressing him thus: “For my
heavenly Father hath revealed it unto thee.” Observe what a difference there is between
these two words which were spoken by Jesus. For to him who had said, “Behold, Thy
mother stands without,” He replied, “Who is my mother, or who are my brethren?” But to
him who said, “Thou art the Christ the Son of the living God,” He makes the return of a
beatitude and benediction. Consequently, if you will have it that He was born of Mary, then
it follows that no less than Peter, He is Himself thus proved to have spoken falsely. But if,
on the other hand, Peter states what is true, then without doubt that former person was in
2022 The text gives, “Virgo castissima et immaculata ecclesia,” = the most pure virgin and spotless church.
But the word “ecclesia” is probably an erroneous addition by the hand of the scribe. Or, as Routh hints, there
may be an allusion, in the word ecclesia, to the beginning of the twelfth chapter of the Apocalypse. [See Pearson,
On the Creed, art. iii. p. 290.]
2023 From this it may perhaps be gathered that Marcellus had now come along with Archelaus to the residence
of Diodorus.
2024 Scribere ausus est. Compare (note 1) p. 224, infra.
2025 Matt. xxii. 42. We read Davidis essefor David Jesse.
2026 Matt. xvi. 16.
526
Chapter XLVII.