Chapter XIV.
He shows how heretics pervert holy Scripture, by replying to the argument drawn from
the Apostle’s words, “Without father, without mother,” etc.: Heb. vii.
You then make use of the holy Scriptures against God, and try to bring His own witnesses
against Him. But how? Truly so as to become a false accuser not only of God, but of the
evidences themselves. Nor indeed is it wonderful that, as you cannot do what you want, you
only do what you can: as you cannot turn the sacred witnesses against God, you do what
you can, and pervert them. For you say: Then Paul tells a lie, when he says of Christ: “Without
mother, without genealogy.”818 I ask you, of whom do you think that Paul said this? Of the
Son and Word of God, or of the Christ, whom you separate from the Son of God, and blas-
phemously assert to be a mere man? If of the Christ, whom you maintain to be a mere man,
how could a man be born without a mother and without a genealogy on the mother’s side?
But if of the Word of God and Son of God—what can we make of it, when the same Apostle,
your own witness, as you impiously imagine, testifies in the same place and by the same
witness, that He whom you assert to be without mother, was also without father; saying,
“Without father, without mother, without genealogy”? It follows then that if you use the
Apostle’s witness, since you assert that the Son of God was “without mother,” you must also
be guilty of the blasphemy that He was “without father.” You see then in what a downfall
of impiety you have landed yourself, in your eagerness for your perversity and wickedness,
so that, while you say that the Son of God had not a mother, you must also deny Him a
Father—a thing which no one yet since the world began, except perhaps a madman, ever
did. And this, whether with greater wickedness or folly, I hardly know; for what is more
foolish and silly than to give the name of Son and to try to keep back the name of Father?
But you say I don’t keep it back, I don’t deny it. And what madness then drove you to quote
that passage, where, while you say that He had no mother, you must seem also to deny to
Him a Father? For as in the same passage He is said to be without mother and also without
father, it follows that if it can be understood that there He is without mother, in the same
way in which we understand that He is without mother, we must also believe that He is
612
without father. But that hasty craze for denying God did not see this; and when it quoted
mutilated, what was written entire, it failed to see that the shameless and palpable lie could
be refuted by laying open the contents of the sacred volume. O foolish blasphemy, and
madness! which, while it failed to see what it ought to follow, had not the wit to see even
what could be read: as if, because it could get rid of its own intelligence, it could get rid of
the power of reading from everybody else, or as if everybody would lose their eyes in their
heads for reading, because it had lost the eyes of the mind. Hear then, you heretic, the passage
you have garbled: hear in full and completely, what you quoted mutilated and hacked about.
818 Heb. vii. 3.
Chapter XIV. He shows how heretics pervert holy Scripture, by replying to the argument drawn from the Apostle's words, “Without father, without mother,” etc.: Heb. vii.
1538
Chapter XIV. He shows how heretics pervert holy Scripture, by replying to…