to the duty which he expects.” And he expresses a great dislike at R. R.‘s supposing, that our
propensities to evil, and temptations, are too strong to be effectually and constantly resisted;
or that we are unavoidably sinful in a degree; that our appetites and passions will be breaking
out, notwithstanding our everlasting watchfulness.” 111 These things fully imply, that men
have in their own natural ability sufficient means to avoid sin, and to be perfectly free from
it; and so, from all the bad consequences of it. And if the means are sufficient, then there is
no need of more; and therefore there is no need of Christ dying, in order to it. What Dr. T.
says, (p. 72. S.) fully implies, that it would be unjust in God to give mankind being in such
circumstances, as that they would be more likely to sin, so as to be exposed to final misery,
than otherwise. Hence then, without Christ and his redemption, and without any grace at
all, mere justice makes sufficient provision for our being free from sin and misery, by our
own power. 112
If all mankind, in all parts of the world, have such sufficient power to do their whole
duty, without being sinful in any degree, then they have sufficient power to obtain righteous-
ness by the law: and then, according to the apostle Paul, Christ is dead in vain. Gal. ii. 21.
“If righteousness come by law, Christ is dead in vain;”—NOT ENGLISH, without the article,
by law, or the rule of right action, as our author explains the phrase. 113 And according to
the sense in which he explains this very place, “it would have frustrated, or rendered useless,
the grace of God, if Christ died to accomplish what was or might have been effected by law
itself, without his death.” 114 So that it most clearly follows from his own doctrine, that
Christ is dead in vain, and the grace of God is useless. The same apostle says, if there had
been a law which could have given life, verily righteousness should have been by the law, Gal.
iii. 21. i. e. (still according to Dr. T.‘s own sense,) if there was a law, that man, in his present
state, had sufficient power perfectly to fulfil. For Dr. T. supposes the reason why the law
could not give life, to be “not because it was weak in itself, but through the weakness of our
flesh, and the infirmity of the human nature in the present state.” 115 But he says, “We are
under a mild dispensation of GRACE, making allowance for our infirmities.” 116 By our
infirmities, we may upon good grounds suppose he means that infirmity of human nature,
which he gives as the reason why the law cannot give life. But what grace is there in making
111 Page 68. S.
112 Here, also, our author will be thought not quite accurate, in the inference lie draws against Dr. T. for the
“sufficient power,” for which Dr. T. pleads, relates only to the prevention of sin, but not to its remission, or the
removal of its effects. But this also will be soon answered.—W.
113 Pref. to Par. on Rom. p. 143. 38.
114 Note on Rom. v. 20. p. 297.
115 Ibid.
116 Page 92. S.
1122
CHAPTER I. Proofs from Redemption by Christ.