Rufinus’
Apology in Defence of Himself.
————————————
Sent to Anastasius, Bishop of
the City of Rome.
————————————
This document was called forth
by accusations against Rufinus made, soon after his accession, to
Anastasius, who held the Roman see from 498 to 503. The authority of
the Roman Popes at this time was not what it afterwards became, and it
is improbable that Anastasius should have summoned Rufinus, as some
suppose him to have done, from Aquileia, where he was living on
confidential terms with the Bishop Chromatius, to come to Rome to
answer a formal accusation or to be judged by him. But since Rome was
the centre of information, a Christian would not wish to be ill-thought
of by its Bishop. Those who accused Rufinus were the friends of Jerome
at Rome, especially the noble widow Marcella and the Senator
Pammachius. They had endeavoured to gain some condemnation of Rufinus
from Siricius before his death in November 398; but Siricius befriended
Rufinus (“his simplicity was imposed on,” according to
Jerome).
2807
On the election of Anastasius,
however, in 399, they accused Rufinus of having, by his translation of
Origen’s
Περὶ
᾽Αρχῶν
introduced heresy into the Roman church. Jerome thus speaks of
Marcella, Ep. cxxvii. 10. “She was the cause of the condemnation
of the heretics: she brought witnesses who had been at a former time
under their instruction, and thus imbued with error and heresy; she
showed how many there were who had been deceived; she had the volumes
of the
Περὶ
᾽Αρχῶν
brought
in, and pointed out the alterations which the Scorpion
2808
had made in them: till at last letters
were written, and that more than once, summoning the heretics to come
and defend themselves, but they did not dare to come. So great was the
force of conviction brought to bear on them that, to prevent their
heresy being exposed in their presence, they chose to stay away and be
condemned.” From the letter of Anastasius to John of Jerusalem
about Rufinus we gather that, while he strongly disapproved the
translation of Origen, he left Rufinus himself to his own conscience,
and did not care to know what had become of him. The letter of Rufinus,
though called an Apology, bears no trace of being an answer to a
summons or judgment of the Pontiff, but merely a reply to statements
which were likely to prejudice him in the Pontiff’s opinion. The
year in which the Apology was written was 400
a.d.
1. It has been brought to my
knowledge that certain persons, in the course of a controversy which
they have been raising in your Holiness’ jurisdiction on matters
of faith or on other points, have made mention of my name. I venture to
believe that your Holiness, who have been trained from your infancy in
the strict principles of the Church, has refused to listen to any
calumnies which may have been directed against an absent person, and
one who has been favourably known to you as united with you in the
faith and love of God. Nevertheless, since I hear it reported that my
reputation has been attacked, I have thought it right to make my
position clear to your Holiness in writing. It was impossible for me to
do this in person. I have just returned to my family
2809
after an absence of nearly 30 years; and
it would have been harsh and almost inhuman to come away again so soon
from those whom I had been so late in revisiting. The labour also of my
long journey has left me too weak to begin the journey again. My object
in this letter is not to remove some stain of suspicion from your mind,
which I regard as a holy place, as a kind of divine sanctuary which
does not admit any evil thing. Rather, I desire that the confession I
am about to make to you may be like a stick placed in your hands to
drive away any envious persons who may be barking like dogs against
me.
2. My faith, indeed, was
sufficiently proved when the heretics persecuted me. I was at that time
sojourning in the church of Alexandria, and underwent imprisonment and
exile which was then the penalty of faithfulness; yet for the sake of
any who may wish to put my faith to the test, or to hear and learn what
it is I will declare it. I believe that the Trinity is of one nature
and godhead, of one and the same power and substance; so that between
the Father, the Son and the Holy Ghost there is no diversity at all,
except that the one is the Father, the second the Son, and the third
the Holy Ghost. There is a Trinity of real and living Persons, a unity
of nature and substance.
3. I also confess that the Son
of God has in these last days been born of the Virgin
and the Holy Spirit:
that he has taken upon him our natural human flesh and soul; that in
this he suffered and was buried and rose again from the dead; that the
flesh in which he rose was that same flesh which had been laid in the
sepulchre; and that in this same flesh, together with the soul, he
ascended into heaven after his resurrection: from whence we look for
his coming to judge the quick and the dead.
4. But, further, as to the
resurrection of our own flesh, I believe that it will be in its
integrity and perfection; it will be this very flesh in which we now
live. We do not hold, as is slanderously reported by some men, that
another flesh will rise instead of this; but this very flesh, without
the loss of a single member, without the cutting off of any single part
of the body; none whatever of all its properties will be absent except
its corruptibility. It is this which is promised by the holy Apostle
concerning the body: It is sown in corruption, it is raised in
incorruption; it is sown in weakness, it is raised in power; it is sown
in dishonour, it is raised in glory; it is sown a natural body, it is
raised a spiritual body. This is the doctrine which has been handed
down to me by those from whom I received holy baptism in the Church of
Aquileia; and I think that it is the same which the Apostolic See has
by long usage handed down and taught.
5. I affirm, moreover, a
judgment to come, in which judgment every man is to receive the due
meed of his bodily life, according to that which he has done, whether
good or evil. And, if in the case of men the reward is to be according
to their works, how much more will this be so in the case of the devil,
who is the universal cause of sin? Of the devil himself our belief is
that which is written in the Gospel, namely, that both he and all his
angels, will receive as their portion the eternal fire, and with him
those who do his works, that is, who become the accusers of their
brethren. If then any one denies that the devil is to be subjected to
the eternal fires, may he have his part with him in the eternal fire,
so that he may know by experience the fact which he now
denies.
6. I am next informed that some
stir has been made on the question of the nature of the soul. Whether
complaints on a matter of this kind ought to be entertained instead of
being put aside, you must yourself decide. If, however, you desire to
know my opinion on the subject, I will state it frankly. I have read a
great many writers on this question, and I find that they express
divers opinions. Some of those whom I have read hold that the soul is
infused together with the material body through the channel
2810
of the human seed; and of this they give
such proofs as they can. I think that this was the opinion of
Tertullian or Lactantius among the Latins, perhaps also of a few
others. Others assert that God is every day making new souls, and
infusing them into the bodies which have been framed in the womb; while
others again believe that the souls were all made long ago, when God
made all things of nothing, and that all that he now does is to plant
out each soul in its body as it seems good to him. This is the opinion
of Origen, and of some others of the Greeks. For myself, I declare in
the presence of God that, after reading each of these opinions, I am up
to the present moment unable to hold any of them as certain and
absolute; the determination of the truth in this question I leave to
God and to any to whom it shall please him to reveal it. My profession
on this point is therefore, first, that these several opinions are
those which I have found in books, but, secondly, that I as yet remain
in ignorance on the subject, except so far as this, that the Church
delivers it as an article of faith that God is the creator of souls as
well as of bodies.
7. Now as to another matter. I
am told that objections have been raised against me because, forsooth,
at the request of some of my brethren, I translated certain works of
Origen from Greek into Latin. I suppose that every one sees that it is
only through ill will that this is made a matter of blame. For, if
there is any offensive statement in the author, why is this to be
twisted into a fault of the translator? I was asked to exhibit in Latin
what stands written in the Greek text; and I did nothing more than fit
the Latin words to the Greek ideas. If, therefore, there is anything to
praise in these ideas, the praise does not belong to me; and similarly
as to anything to which blame may attach. I admit that I put something
of my own into the work; as I stated in my Preface, I used my own
discretion in cutting out not a few passages; but only those as to
which I had come to suspect that the thing had not been so stated by
Origen himself; and the statement appeared to me in these cases to have
been inserted by others, because in other places I
had found the author state the
matter in a catholic sense. I entreat you therefore, holy, venerable
and saintly father, not to permit a storm of ill will to be raised
against me because of this, nor to sanction the employment of
partisanship and of calumny—weapons which ought never to be used
in the Church of God. Where can simple faith and innocence be safe if
they are not protected in the Church? I am not a defender or a champion
of Origen; nor am I the first who has translated his works. Others
before me had done the very same thing, and I did it, the last of many,
at the request of my brethren. If an order is to be given that such
translations are not to be made, such an order holds good for the
future, not the past; but if those are to be blamed who have made these
translations before any such order was given, the blame must begin with
those who took the first step.
8. As for me, I declare in
Christ’s name that I never held, nor ever will hold, any other
faith but that which I have set forth above, that is, the faith which
is held by the Church of Rome, by that of Alexandria, and by my own
church of Aquileia; and which is also preached at Jerusalem; and if
there is any one who believes otherwise, whoever he may be, let him be
Anathema. But those who through mere ill will and malice engender
dissensions and offences among their brethren, and cause them to
stumble, shall give account of it in the day of judgment.
2807
Jerome Letter cxxvii. 9.
2808
The Scorpion is Jerome’s name for Rufinus, especially after
his death. He means that Rufinus had altered the too palpable
expressions of heresy, so that the more subtle expressions of it might
gain acceptance.
2809
Rufinus uses the word
“parentes.”
Jerome in his
Apology (ii, 2) scoffs at the notion that a man of Rufinus’ age
(about 55) could have parents living, and supposes that he is making a
false suggestion by using the word in the sense in which it was
vulgarly used—that of relations generally, as it is now used in
French.
2810
Traducem, properly, the layer, by which the vine is propagated,
and hence the medium through which life is communicated. This is the
theory of the “traducianists” who thus made the soul to be
derived from the parent by procreation. It is contrasted with that of
the “creationists” who held that each soul was separately
created, and infused into the child at the moment when life
began.