England, to be ordained by the Tennents.” Those who have an opportunity of reading these
communications, will find, in those of Mr. Edwards, an example of a personal controversy,
conducted throughout, and to a very uncommon degree, in the spirit of the gentleman and
the Christian.
This occurred at a period of great excitement, when many ministers had been removed,
and many churches rent asunder; and when the minds of men were of course prepared be-
forehand to believe every thing that favoured their own side of the question. Mr. Clap was
in this case obviously mistaken; still he was truly a man of respectability and worth. He had
a powerful mind, rich in invention, and stored with knowledge, was profoundly versed in
mathematics, physics, and astronomy, as well as the principles of law, and proved an able
instructor and governor of the institution over which he presided. He was elected by a board
of trustees, exclusively Arminian in sentiment, and all his associates in office held the same
tenets. At the same time, though he entered warmly into the controversy relative to Mr.
Whitefield, from a full conviction that it was his design to occasion the separation of churches,
and to procure as far as possible the ejectment of all whom he regarded as unconverted
ministers; and was doubtless happy in supposing himself able to prove that such was his
avowed design, on the testimony of one of his warmest friends; yet he was far from taking
the low ground of orthodoxy assumed by many on the same side, but always adhered to the
doctrines of grace, and ultimately became their champion. Some time after this, he showed
his magnanimity, by introducing the Essay on the Freedom of the Will, as a classic in the
college.
In August, 1744, Mr. Edwards preached the sermon entitled, “The True Excellency of
a Gospel Minister,” at the ordination of Mr. Robert Abercrombie, to the ministry of the
gospel, at Pelham. This gentleman was from Scotland, having been made known to Mr.
Edwards by his correspondents in that country; and through his kind offices was introduced
to the people at Pelham. The sermon was immediately published.
The reader will probably recollect, that Mr. M’Culloch, in his letter of August 13, 1743,
had expressed the opinion, that the church of God, previous to her ultimate extension and
triumph, was destined to meet with “more extensive and formidable trials,” than she had
ever before experienced. Mr. Edwards, from a minute investigation of the scriptural
prophecies, having been convinced that this, which was at that time the commonly received
opinion of the church, was erroneous; expresses his dissent from it in the following answer.
“To the Rev. Mr. M’Culloch.
Northampton, March 5, 1744.
rev. and dear sir,
I return you thanks for your most obliging, entertaining, and instructive letter, dated
Aug. 13, 1743, which I received about the latter end of October: my answering which has
been unhappily delayed, by reason of my distance from Boston, and not being able to find
155
Chapter XIII. First Interview with David Brainerd--Separations From Churches--Letter…