taken singly, or by themselves, that they are truly godly or gracious, though when we look
on the whole number in the gross, we are far from determining that every one is a true saint,
and that not one of the judgments we have passed, has been mistaken; Mr. W. because I
used the phrase singly taken, has laid hold on the expression, and from thence has taken
occasion to insinuate to his readers, as if my scheme were so very extravagant, that according
to this, when a great multitude are admitted, their admitters must be confident of every
one’s being regenerated. Hence he observes, (p. 98. c.) “There is no appearance, that John
490
made a positive judgment that every one of these people were regenerated. Plainly using the
expression as a very strong one; leading the reader to suppose, that I insist the evidence shall
be so clear, that when such a vast multitude as John baptized are viewed, the admitter should
be peremptory in it, that his judgment has not failed so much as in a single instance; the
very reverse of what I had expressed. In like manner, Mr. W. treats the matter from time to
time. As in p. 55. a. “The thing to be proved from hence is, that the apostles and primitive
Christians, not only thought that these persons were Christians, by reason of their external
calling, and professed compliance with the call; but had formed a positive judgment con-
cerning every one of them singly, that they were real saints.” Here the expression is plainly
used as a very strong one; as implying much more than esteeming so great a multitude,
when taken in the gross, to be generally true saints, and with a manifest design to carry the
same idea in the mind of the reader as was before mentioned. See another like instance, p.
62. c.
V. However, my opinion is not represented bad enough yet; but to make it appear still
worse, Mr. W. is bold to strain his representation of it to that height, as to suggest that what
I insist on, is a certainty of others’ regeneration; though this be so diverse from what I had
largely explained in stating the question, and plainly expressed in other parts of my book,
384 and also inconsistent with his own representations in other places. For if what I insist
on be a probability that may fail once in ten times, as he says it is, p. 63. a. then it is not a
certainty that I insist on; as he suggests, p. 141. a.—Speaking of the evil consequences of my
opinion, he says, “The notion of men’s being able and fit to determine positively the condition
of other men, or the certainty of their gracious estate, has a direct tendency to deceive the
souls of men.” So again in p 69. And he suggests, that I require more than moral evidence,
in p. 6. c. and p. 139. d.
VI. Mr. W. represents me as insisting on some way of judging the state of such as are
admitted to communion, by their inward and spiritual experiences, diverse from judging by
384 In stating the question, p. 5. b. I explained the requisite visibility, to be some outward manifestation, that
ordinarily renders the thing probable. To the like purpose, is what I lay in p 10. c. and p. 11 a. b c. and p 12. a.
b. c. And in p 106. c. I say expressly, “Not a certainty, but a profession and visibility of these things, must be the
rule of the church’s proceeding.
1908
SECTION II. Degrees of evidence.